| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Title of host publication | Handbook of Psycholinguistics, Second Edition |
| Editors | Matthew J. Traxler, Morton A. Gernsbacher |
| Place of Publication | Amsterdam ; Boston |
| Publisher | Elsevier |
| Pages | 1073-1110 |
| Number of pages | 38 |
| ISBN (Print) | 9780123693747 |
| DOIs | |
| Publication status | Published - 2006 |
Abstract
This chapter discusses reviews the results from experimental investigations of child language. Chomsky (1971) maintained that children would never adopt structure-independent hypotheses, even if the data available to children were consistent with both structure-independent and structure-dependent rules. In other words, children would not be expected to make certain kinds of mistakes in forming Yes/No questions at any stage in language development. In an elicited production study, Crain and Nakayama (1987) evoked Yes/No questions from 30, 3 to 5year-old children, to see if they ever made such mistakes. Although children made certain kinds of errors, they never produced questions that are consistent with structure-independent rules. It has frequently been claimed by advocates of the experience-dependent approach that nativists assume that "no evidence exists that would enable a three-year-old to unlearn" mistaken structure-independent rules, if children were to initially adopt such rules. But no reasonable nativist would endorse such a strong claim about all possible evidence.