Against the use and publication of contemporary unethical research: the case of Chinese transplant research

Wendy C. Higgins, Wendy A. Rogers, Angela Ballantyne, Wendy Lipworth

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent calls for retraction of a large body of Chinese transplant research and of Dr Jiankui He's gene editing research has led to renewed interest in the question of publication, retraction and use of unethical biomedical research. In Part 1 of this paper, we briefly review the now well-established consequentialist and deontological arguments for and against the use of unethical research. We argue that, while there are potentially compelling justifications for use under some circumstances, these justifications fail when unethical practices are ongoing-as in the case of research involving transplantations in which organs have been procured unethically from executed prisoners. Use of such research displays a lack of respect and concern for the victims and undermines efforts to deter unethical practices. Such use also creates moral taint and renders those who use the research complicit in continuing harm. In Part 2, we distinguish three dimensions of 'non-use' of unethical research: non-use of published unethical research, non-publication, and retraction and argue that all three types of non-use should be upheld in the case of Chinese transplant research. Publishers have responsibilities to not publish contemporary unethical biomedical research, and where this has occurred, to retract publications. Failure to retract the papers implicitly condones the research, while uptake of the research through citations rewards researchers and ongoing circulation of the data in the literature facilitates subsequent use by researchers, policymakers and clinicians.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)678-684
Number of pages7
JournalJournal of Medical Ethics
Volume46
Issue number10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2020

Keywords

  • donation/procurement of organs/tissues
  • prisoners
  • publication ethics
  • research ethics
  • transplantation
  • tissues
  • donation
  • procurement of organs

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Against the use and publication of contemporary unethical research: the case of Chinese transplant research'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this