Can magmatic water contents be estimated from clinopyroxene phenocrysts in some lavas? A case study with implications for the origin of the Azores Islands

Michael Turner, Simon Turner, Nikita Mironov, Maxim Portnyagin, Kaj Hoernle

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Over the last decade there has been renewed interest in determining the water contents of basaltic magmas. A commonly applied method is analysis of H2O from melt inclusions in olivine. However, it is also well known that these can rapidly lose (or gain) H2O by diffusion. An alternative is to measure the H2O contents of clinopyroxene phenocrysts and use a partition coefficient (D) to estimate the original H2O content of the host magma. This approach is not without complications and several recent studies have attempted to assess the effects of diffusive loss of H2O from magmatic clinopyroxenes. In the ideal case, these crystals should be taken from rapidly cooled tephra or lapilli but such materials are not always available. In order to further assess the potential of using 5-10mm clinopyroxenes from lavas we undertook a detailed, multi-analytical investigation of clinopyroxenes from an ankaramite flow on Pico Island in the Azores. We conclude that these can be trusted to preserve (probably minimum) magmatic H2O contents if the H2O concentrations of multiple clinopyroxenes from a single sample form a linear correlation with the AlIV content that demonstrates a coupled substitution with little or no H2O loss. Conversely, if H2O contents decrease from core to rim whereas AlIV contents remain relatively constant then it is likely that those clinopyroxenes lost H2O during differentiation and/or cooling. We suspect that the olivine melt inclusions we analysed from Pico and São Miguel Islands also underwent diffusive loss of H2O. Using these criteria, we present clinopyroxene-derived magmatic H2O estimates for Corvo, Flores Faial, Pico and São Miguel Islands that range from 0.28 to 2.2wt%. When combined with published data these show that H2O contents often extend to higher values on the islands than along the adjacent mid-Atlantic ridge. These localised, elevated H2O contents can explain why the islands are emergent despite being situated away from the ridge and perhaps also the asymmetric nature of the bathymetry of the archipelago. It is possible that this H2O was recycled from material subducted very early on in Earth's history.

LanguageEnglish
Pages436-445
Number of pages10
JournalChemical Geology
Volume466
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 5 Sep 2017

Fingerprint

clinopyroxene
Water content
water content
melt inclusion
Bathymetry
olivine
Substitution reactions
Earth (planet)
History
Cooling
tephra
Crystals
partition coefficient
bathymetry
archipelago
substitution
magma
crystal
cooling
history

Keywords

  • Azores
  • clinopyroxene
  • magmatic H2O contents
  • melt inclusions
  • SHRIMP-SI analysis

Cite this

@article{57fce5daaf1241d98475aa74a706856a,
title = "Can magmatic water contents be estimated from clinopyroxene phenocrysts in some lavas? A case study with implications for the origin of the Azores Islands",
abstract = "Over the last decade there has been renewed interest in determining the water contents of basaltic magmas. A commonly applied method is analysis of H2O from melt inclusions in olivine. However, it is also well known that these can rapidly lose (or gain) H2O by diffusion. An alternative is to measure the H2O contents of clinopyroxene phenocrysts and use a partition coefficient (D) to estimate the original H2O content of the host magma. This approach is not without complications and several recent studies have attempted to assess the effects of diffusive loss of H2O from magmatic clinopyroxenes. In the ideal case, these crystals should be taken from rapidly cooled tephra or lapilli but such materials are not always available. In order to further assess the potential of using 5-10mm clinopyroxenes from lavas we undertook a detailed, multi-analytical investigation of clinopyroxenes from an ankaramite flow on Pico Island in the Azores. We conclude that these can be trusted to preserve (probably minimum) magmatic H2O contents if the H2O concentrations of multiple clinopyroxenes from a single sample form a linear correlation with the AlIV content that demonstrates a coupled substitution with little or no H2O loss. Conversely, if H2O contents decrease from core to rim whereas AlIV contents remain relatively constant then it is likely that those clinopyroxenes lost H2O during differentiation and/or cooling. We suspect that the olivine melt inclusions we analysed from Pico and S{\~a}o Miguel Islands also underwent diffusive loss of H2O. Using these criteria, we present clinopyroxene-derived magmatic H2O estimates for Corvo, Flores Faial, Pico and S{\~a}o Miguel Islands that range from 0.28 to 2.2wt{\%}. When combined with published data these show that H2O contents often extend to higher values on the islands than along the adjacent mid-Atlantic ridge. These localised, elevated H2O contents can explain why the islands are emergent despite being situated away from the ridge and perhaps also the asymmetric nature of the bathymetry of the archipelago. It is possible that this H2O was recycled from material subducted very early on in Earth's history.",
keywords = "Azores, clinopyroxene, magmatic H2O contents, melt inclusions, SHRIMP-SI analysis",
author = "Michael Turner and Simon Turner and Nikita Mironov and Maxim Portnyagin and Kaj Hoernle",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.chemgeo.2017.06.032",
language = "English",
volume = "466",
pages = "436--445",
journal = "Chemical Geology",
issn = "0009-2541",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Can magmatic water contents be estimated from clinopyroxene phenocrysts in some lavas? A case study with implications for the origin of the Azores Islands. / Turner, Michael; Turner, Simon; Mironov, Nikita; Portnyagin, Maxim; Hoernle, Kaj.

In: Chemical Geology, Vol. 466, 05.09.2017, p. 436-445.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Can magmatic water contents be estimated from clinopyroxene phenocrysts in some lavas? A case study with implications for the origin of the Azores Islands

AU - Turner, Michael

AU - Turner, Simon

AU - Mironov, Nikita

AU - Portnyagin, Maxim

AU - Hoernle, Kaj

PY - 2017/9/5

Y1 - 2017/9/5

N2 - Over the last decade there has been renewed interest in determining the water contents of basaltic magmas. A commonly applied method is analysis of H2O from melt inclusions in olivine. However, it is also well known that these can rapidly lose (or gain) H2O by diffusion. An alternative is to measure the H2O contents of clinopyroxene phenocrysts and use a partition coefficient (D) to estimate the original H2O content of the host magma. This approach is not without complications and several recent studies have attempted to assess the effects of diffusive loss of H2O from magmatic clinopyroxenes. In the ideal case, these crystals should be taken from rapidly cooled tephra or lapilli but such materials are not always available. In order to further assess the potential of using 5-10mm clinopyroxenes from lavas we undertook a detailed, multi-analytical investigation of clinopyroxenes from an ankaramite flow on Pico Island in the Azores. We conclude that these can be trusted to preserve (probably minimum) magmatic H2O contents if the H2O concentrations of multiple clinopyroxenes from a single sample form a linear correlation with the AlIV content that demonstrates a coupled substitution with little or no H2O loss. Conversely, if H2O contents decrease from core to rim whereas AlIV contents remain relatively constant then it is likely that those clinopyroxenes lost H2O during differentiation and/or cooling. We suspect that the olivine melt inclusions we analysed from Pico and São Miguel Islands also underwent diffusive loss of H2O. Using these criteria, we present clinopyroxene-derived magmatic H2O estimates for Corvo, Flores Faial, Pico and São Miguel Islands that range from 0.28 to 2.2wt%. When combined with published data these show that H2O contents often extend to higher values on the islands than along the adjacent mid-Atlantic ridge. These localised, elevated H2O contents can explain why the islands are emergent despite being situated away from the ridge and perhaps also the asymmetric nature of the bathymetry of the archipelago. It is possible that this H2O was recycled from material subducted very early on in Earth's history.

AB - Over the last decade there has been renewed interest in determining the water contents of basaltic magmas. A commonly applied method is analysis of H2O from melt inclusions in olivine. However, it is also well known that these can rapidly lose (or gain) H2O by diffusion. An alternative is to measure the H2O contents of clinopyroxene phenocrysts and use a partition coefficient (D) to estimate the original H2O content of the host magma. This approach is not without complications and several recent studies have attempted to assess the effects of diffusive loss of H2O from magmatic clinopyroxenes. In the ideal case, these crystals should be taken from rapidly cooled tephra or lapilli but such materials are not always available. In order to further assess the potential of using 5-10mm clinopyroxenes from lavas we undertook a detailed, multi-analytical investigation of clinopyroxenes from an ankaramite flow on Pico Island in the Azores. We conclude that these can be trusted to preserve (probably minimum) magmatic H2O contents if the H2O concentrations of multiple clinopyroxenes from a single sample form a linear correlation with the AlIV content that demonstrates a coupled substitution with little or no H2O loss. Conversely, if H2O contents decrease from core to rim whereas AlIV contents remain relatively constant then it is likely that those clinopyroxenes lost H2O during differentiation and/or cooling. We suspect that the olivine melt inclusions we analysed from Pico and São Miguel Islands also underwent diffusive loss of H2O. Using these criteria, we present clinopyroxene-derived magmatic H2O estimates for Corvo, Flores Faial, Pico and São Miguel Islands that range from 0.28 to 2.2wt%. When combined with published data these show that H2O contents often extend to higher values on the islands than along the adjacent mid-Atlantic ridge. These localised, elevated H2O contents can explain why the islands are emergent despite being situated away from the ridge and perhaps also the asymmetric nature of the bathymetry of the archipelago. It is possible that this H2O was recycled from material subducted very early on in Earth's history.

KW - Azores

KW - clinopyroxene

KW - magmatic H2O contents

KW - melt inclusions

KW - SHRIMP-SI analysis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85021258416&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.chemgeo.2017.06.032

DO - 10.1016/j.chemgeo.2017.06.032

M3 - Article

VL - 466

SP - 436

EP - 445

JO - Chemical Geology

T2 - Chemical Geology

JF - Chemical Geology

SN - 0009-2541

ER -