Diagnostic efficiency of imPACT and cogsport in concussed rugby union players who have not undergone baseline neurocognitive testing

Andrew Gardner, E. Arthur Shores, Jennifer Batchelor, Cynthia A. Honan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The current study endeavored to replicate the approach to sports-related concussion management adopted by some community-based sporting organizations by examining the diagnostic efficiency of CogSport and ImPACT in athletes without baseline test data and assessed only once postinjury. Recently concussed nonelite-level rugby union players (N=51) were tested within 72 hours of sustaining a concussion and were compared to nonconcussed matched controls (N=41). Demographic information and history of recent concussion were also collected. Logistic regression analysis and receiver-operating characteristic curve analysis were conducted to evaluate the most accurate scores at identifying group membership. Overall, the classification accuracy of CogSport and ImPACT represented only very minimal improvements over a demographic-only (age, estimated premorbid Full-Scale IQ, and number of previous concussions) model. Positive predictive power and negative predictive power of composite scores were modest. The ImPACT postconcussion symptoms total (severity) score was most accurate at classifying concussed athletes. Where neuropsychological tests are utilized on a single occasion postconcussion and in the absence of baseline testing, postinjury testing does not improve diagnostic utility beyond the demographic model. These results do not validate this approach as a useful method of managing sports-related concussion.

LanguageEnglish
Pages90-97
Number of pages8
JournalApplied Neuropsychology
Volume19
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2012

Fingerprint

Football
Demography
Athletes
Sports
Neuropsychological Tests
ROC Curve
Logistic Models
Regression Analysis
Organizations

Cite this

@article{dc0a3353424f40dfa7d0369c4f88267a,
title = "Diagnostic efficiency of imPACT and cogsport in concussed rugby union players who have not undergone baseline neurocognitive testing",
abstract = "The current study endeavored to replicate the approach to sports-related concussion management adopted by some community-based sporting organizations by examining the diagnostic efficiency of CogSport and ImPACT in athletes without baseline test data and assessed only once postinjury. Recently concussed nonelite-level rugby union players (N=51) were tested within 72 hours of sustaining a concussion and were compared to nonconcussed matched controls (N=41). Demographic information and history of recent concussion were also collected. Logistic regression analysis and receiver-operating characteristic curve analysis were conducted to evaluate the most accurate scores at identifying group membership. Overall, the classification accuracy of CogSport and ImPACT represented only very minimal improvements over a demographic-only (age, estimated premorbid Full-Scale IQ, and number of previous concussions) model. Positive predictive power and negative predictive power of composite scores were modest. The ImPACT postconcussion symptoms total (severity) score was most accurate at classifying concussed athletes. Where neuropsychological tests are utilized on a single occasion postconcussion and in the absence of baseline testing, postinjury testing does not improve diagnostic utility beyond the demographic model. These results do not validate this approach as a useful method of managing sports-related concussion.",
author = "Andrew Gardner and Shores, {E. Arthur} and Jennifer Batchelor and Honan, {Cynthia A.}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/09084282.2011.643945",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "90--97",
journal = "Applied Neuropsychology",
issn = "0908-4282",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "2",

}

Diagnostic efficiency of imPACT and cogsport in concussed rugby union players who have not undergone baseline neurocognitive testing. / Gardner, Andrew; Shores, E. Arthur; Batchelor, Jennifer; Honan, Cynthia A.

In: Applied Neuropsychology, Vol. 19, No. 2, 01.04.2012, p. 90-97.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Diagnostic efficiency of imPACT and cogsport in concussed rugby union players who have not undergone baseline neurocognitive testing

AU - Gardner, Andrew

AU - Shores, E. Arthur

AU - Batchelor, Jennifer

AU - Honan, Cynthia A.

PY - 2012/4/1

Y1 - 2012/4/1

N2 - The current study endeavored to replicate the approach to sports-related concussion management adopted by some community-based sporting organizations by examining the diagnostic efficiency of CogSport and ImPACT in athletes without baseline test data and assessed only once postinjury. Recently concussed nonelite-level rugby union players (N=51) were tested within 72 hours of sustaining a concussion and were compared to nonconcussed matched controls (N=41). Demographic information and history of recent concussion were also collected. Logistic regression analysis and receiver-operating characteristic curve analysis were conducted to evaluate the most accurate scores at identifying group membership. Overall, the classification accuracy of CogSport and ImPACT represented only very minimal improvements over a demographic-only (age, estimated premorbid Full-Scale IQ, and number of previous concussions) model. Positive predictive power and negative predictive power of composite scores were modest. The ImPACT postconcussion symptoms total (severity) score was most accurate at classifying concussed athletes. Where neuropsychological tests are utilized on a single occasion postconcussion and in the absence of baseline testing, postinjury testing does not improve diagnostic utility beyond the demographic model. These results do not validate this approach as a useful method of managing sports-related concussion.

AB - The current study endeavored to replicate the approach to sports-related concussion management adopted by some community-based sporting organizations by examining the diagnostic efficiency of CogSport and ImPACT in athletes without baseline test data and assessed only once postinjury. Recently concussed nonelite-level rugby union players (N=51) were tested within 72 hours of sustaining a concussion and were compared to nonconcussed matched controls (N=41). Demographic information and history of recent concussion were also collected. Logistic regression analysis and receiver-operating characteristic curve analysis were conducted to evaluate the most accurate scores at identifying group membership. Overall, the classification accuracy of CogSport and ImPACT represented only very minimal improvements over a demographic-only (age, estimated premorbid Full-Scale IQ, and number of previous concussions) model. Positive predictive power and negative predictive power of composite scores were modest. The ImPACT postconcussion symptoms total (severity) score was most accurate at classifying concussed athletes. Where neuropsychological tests are utilized on a single occasion postconcussion and in the absence of baseline testing, postinjury testing does not improve diagnostic utility beyond the demographic model. These results do not validate this approach as a useful method of managing sports-related concussion.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84861943536&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/09084282.2011.643945

DO - 10.1080/09084282.2011.643945

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 90

EP - 97

JO - Applied Neuropsychology

T2 - Applied Neuropsychology

JF - Applied Neuropsychology

SN - 0908-4282

IS - 2

ER -