Eminem v. Rambo: A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities

Wayne Warburton, Lana Gilmour, Peta Laczkowski

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

It is well established that exposure to violent visual media is associated with increases in aggressive thoughts, feelings and behaviours. However, research regarding the effects of exposure to violent music is more scarce and has returned inconsistent findings. In their review of the literature, Roberts, Christenson and Gentile (2003) suggested that (1) the angry tone of violent music has a much stronger effect on aggressive behaviour than does exposure to violent lyrics, and (2) that the effects of violent music exposure on aggression are not widespread. In this study both assertions were tested. Participants (N=309) were measured for levels of trait aggression, selfreported actual aggression, and exposure to violent visual and auditory media. Exposure to violent visual media and exposure to violent music were both significantly correlated with trait and actual aggression, and the size of the effect was similar for both modes. When the effects were examined in detail, it was found that whereas exposure to violent visual media had a stronger effect on levels of physical aggression, exposure to violent music had a stronger effect on levels of indirect and displaced aggression. In addition, the effect of exposure to violent lyrics was found to be similar in strength to the effect of exposure to music with a violent 'tone'. The implications of these findings for current theories of media violence effects are discussed.

LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationPersonality Down Under
Subtitle of host publicationPerspectives from Australia
EditorsSimon Boag
Place of PublicationNew York
PublisherNova Science Publishers
Pages253-272
Number of pages20
ISBN (Print)9781604567946
Publication statusPublished - 2008

Fingerprint

violence
aggression
music
auditory media
aggressive behavior

Cite this

Warburton, W., Gilmour, L., & Laczkowski, P. (2008). Eminem v. Rambo: A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities. In S. Boag (Ed.), Personality Down Under: Perspectives from Australia (pp. 253-272). New York: Nova Science Publishers.
Warburton, Wayne ; Gilmour, Lana ; Laczkowski, Peta. / Eminem v. Rambo : A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities. Personality Down Under: Perspectives from Australia. editor / Simon Boag. New York : Nova Science Publishers, 2008. pp. 253-272
@inbook{82247b2228fd479c9d1df13f54acea6c,
title = "Eminem v. Rambo: A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities",
abstract = "It is well established that exposure to violent visual media is associated with increases in aggressive thoughts, feelings and behaviours. However, research regarding the effects of exposure to violent music is more scarce and has returned inconsistent findings. In their review of the literature, Roberts, Christenson and Gentile (2003) suggested that (1) the angry tone of violent music has a much stronger effect on aggressive behaviour than does exposure to violent lyrics, and (2) that the effects of violent music exposure on aggression are not widespread. In this study both assertions were tested. Participants (N=309) were measured for levels of trait aggression, selfreported actual aggression, and exposure to violent visual and auditory media. Exposure to violent visual media and exposure to violent music were both significantly correlated with trait and actual aggression, and the size of the effect was similar for both modes. When the effects were examined in detail, it was found that whereas exposure to violent visual media had a stronger effect on levels of physical aggression, exposure to violent music had a stronger effect on levels of indirect and displaced aggression. In addition, the effect of exposure to violent lyrics was found to be similar in strength to the effect of exposure to music with a violent 'tone'. The implications of these findings for current theories of media violence effects are discussed.",
author = "Wayne Warburton and Lana Gilmour and Peta Laczkowski",
year = "2008",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781604567946",
pages = "253--272",
editor = "Simon Boag",
booktitle = "Personality Down Under",
publisher = "Nova Science Publishers",
address = "United States",

}

Warburton, W, Gilmour, L & Laczkowski, P 2008, Eminem v. Rambo: A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities. in S Boag (ed.), Personality Down Under: Perspectives from Australia. Nova Science Publishers, New York, pp. 253-272.

Eminem v. Rambo : A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities. / Warburton, Wayne; Gilmour, Lana; Laczkowski, Peta.

Personality Down Under: Perspectives from Australia. ed. / Simon Boag. New York : Nova Science Publishers, 2008. p. 253-272.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Eminem v. Rambo

T2 - A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities

AU - Warburton, Wayne

AU - Gilmour, Lana

AU - Laczkowski, Peta

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - It is well established that exposure to violent visual media is associated with increases in aggressive thoughts, feelings and behaviours. However, research regarding the effects of exposure to violent music is more scarce and has returned inconsistent findings. In their review of the literature, Roberts, Christenson and Gentile (2003) suggested that (1) the angry tone of violent music has a much stronger effect on aggressive behaviour than does exposure to violent lyrics, and (2) that the effects of violent music exposure on aggression are not widespread. In this study both assertions were tested. Participants (N=309) were measured for levels of trait aggression, selfreported actual aggression, and exposure to violent visual and auditory media. Exposure to violent visual media and exposure to violent music were both significantly correlated with trait and actual aggression, and the size of the effect was similar for both modes. When the effects were examined in detail, it was found that whereas exposure to violent visual media had a stronger effect on levels of physical aggression, exposure to violent music had a stronger effect on levels of indirect and displaced aggression. In addition, the effect of exposure to violent lyrics was found to be similar in strength to the effect of exposure to music with a violent 'tone'. The implications of these findings for current theories of media violence effects are discussed.

AB - It is well established that exposure to violent visual media is associated with increases in aggressive thoughts, feelings and behaviours. However, research regarding the effects of exposure to violent music is more scarce and has returned inconsistent findings. In their review of the literature, Roberts, Christenson and Gentile (2003) suggested that (1) the angry tone of violent music has a much stronger effect on aggressive behaviour than does exposure to violent lyrics, and (2) that the effects of violent music exposure on aggression are not widespread. In this study both assertions were tested. Participants (N=309) were measured for levels of trait aggression, selfreported actual aggression, and exposure to violent visual and auditory media. Exposure to violent visual media and exposure to violent music were both significantly correlated with trait and actual aggression, and the size of the effect was similar for both modes. When the effects were examined in detail, it was found that whereas exposure to violent visual media had a stronger effect on levels of physical aggression, exposure to violent music had a stronger effect on levels of indirect and displaced aggression. In addition, the effect of exposure to violent lyrics was found to be similar in strength to the effect of exposure to music with a violent 'tone'. The implications of these findings for current theories of media violence effects are discussed.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79955144357&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781604567946

SP - 253

EP - 272

BT - Personality Down Under

A2 - Boag, Simon

PB - Nova Science Publishers

CY - New York

ER -

Warburton W, Gilmour L, Laczkowski P. Eminem v. Rambo: A comparison of media violence effects for auditory versus visual modalities. In Boag S, editor, Personality Down Under: Perspectives from Australia. New York: Nova Science Publishers. 2008. p. 253-272