Erasing alterity: gendered characterisation in the different versions of Vita Anastasiae

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Despite official declarations against cross-dressing in the fourth century, eleven uitae that praise the ascetic superiority of cross-dressing female saints were produced in late antiquity. Engaging in a practice that was explicitly forbidden by numerous ecclesiastical synods, women who cross-dressed were often labelled as 'others' because they resisted social expectations and gender norms and trespassed into the masculine realms of independence and holiness. This study examines the gendered representation of one of these cross-dressing female saints named Anastasia. It traces her gendered representation across three versions of her Greek uita, two of which are preserved in Vita Danielis and one in the Greek Menaion. These texts are fascinating because of the differing degrees to which they tolerate and promote the gender ambiguity of the heroine. While the former versions allow Anastasia a degree of gender ambiguity, the Menaion version suppresses much of this ambiguity. I will demonstrate this by exploring three aspects of Anastasia's gendered characterisation in the texts: 1) designations for her throughout each narrative; 2) her identification as a eunuch; and 3) the degree of agency attributed to her. I conclude by offering some thoughts about how alterity theory can help account for these different representations, which I argue are responses to the perceived alterity of the saint.

LanguageEnglish
Pages19-46
Number of pages28
JournalJournal of the Australian Early Medieval Association
Volume13
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Alterity
Cross-dressing
Saints
Heroine
Eunuch
Superiority
Ascetic
Declaration
Synod
Holiness
Designation
Late Antiquity
Masculine

Keywords

  • Vita Anastasiae
  • Life of Anastasia
  • cross-dressing
  • monasticism
  • late antiquity
  • gender
  • eunuch
  • saint
  • Menaion
  • Hagiography
  • Vita Danielis
  • Egyptian monasticism
  • sexuality and gender
  • alterity

Cite this

@article{c5a7a35fd3c644ff973367787fc9205a,
title = "Erasing alterity: gendered characterisation in the different versions of Vita Anastasiae",
abstract = "Despite official declarations against cross-dressing in the fourth century, eleven uitae that praise the ascetic superiority of cross-dressing female saints were produced in late antiquity. Engaging in a practice that was explicitly forbidden by numerous ecclesiastical synods, women who cross-dressed were often labelled as 'others' because they resisted social expectations and gender norms and trespassed into the masculine realms of independence and holiness. This study examines the gendered representation of one of these cross-dressing female saints named Anastasia. It traces her gendered representation across three versions of her Greek uita, two of which are preserved in Vita Danielis and one in the Greek Menaion. These texts are fascinating because of the differing degrees to which they tolerate and promote the gender ambiguity of the heroine. While the former versions allow Anastasia a degree of gender ambiguity, the Menaion version suppresses much of this ambiguity. I will demonstrate this by exploring three aspects of Anastasia's gendered characterisation in the texts: 1) designations for her throughout each narrative; 2) her identification as a eunuch; and 3) the degree of agency attributed to her. I conclude by offering some thoughts about how alterity theory can help account for these different representations, which I argue are responses to the perceived alterity of the saint.",
keywords = "Vita Anastasiae, Life of Anastasia, cross-dressing, monasticism, late antiquity, gender, eunuch, saint, Menaion, Hagiography, Vita Danielis, Egyptian monasticism, sexuality and gender, alterity",
author = "Natalie Mylonas",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "19--46",
journal = "Journal of the Australian Early Medieval Association",
issn = "1449-9320",
publisher = "Australian Early Medieval Association",

}

Erasing alterity : gendered characterisation in the different versions of Vita Anastasiae. / Mylonas, Natalie.

In: Journal of the Australian Early Medieval Association, Vol. 13, 2017, p. 19-46.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Erasing alterity

T2 - Journal of the Australian Early Medieval Association

AU - Mylonas, Natalie

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Despite official declarations against cross-dressing in the fourth century, eleven uitae that praise the ascetic superiority of cross-dressing female saints were produced in late antiquity. Engaging in a practice that was explicitly forbidden by numerous ecclesiastical synods, women who cross-dressed were often labelled as 'others' because they resisted social expectations and gender norms and trespassed into the masculine realms of independence and holiness. This study examines the gendered representation of one of these cross-dressing female saints named Anastasia. It traces her gendered representation across three versions of her Greek uita, two of which are preserved in Vita Danielis and one in the Greek Menaion. These texts are fascinating because of the differing degrees to which they tolerate and promote the gender ambiguity of the heroine. While the former versions allow Anastasia a degree of gender ambiguity, the Menaion version suppresses much of this ambiguity. I will demonstrate this by exploring three aspects of Anastasia's gendered characterisation in the texts: 1) designations for her throughout each narrative; 2) her identification as a eunuch; and 3) the degree of agency attributed to her. I conclude by offering some thoughts about how alterity theory can help account for these different representations, which I argue are responses to the perceived alterity of the saint.

AB - Despite official declarations against cross-dressing in the fourth century, eleven uitae that praise the ascetic superiority of cross-dressing female saints were produced in late antiquity. Engaging in a practice that was explicitly forbidden by numerous ecclesiastical synods, women who cross-dressed were often labelled as 'others' because they resisted social expectations and gender norms and trespassed into the masculine realms of independence and holiness. This study examines the gendered representation of one of these cross-dressing female saints named Anastasia. It traces her gendered representation across three versions of her Greek uita, two of which are preserved in Vita Danielis and one in the Greek Menaion. These texts are fascinating because of the differing degrees to which they tolerate and promote the gender ambiguity of the heroine. While the former versions allow Anastasia a degree of gender ambiguity, the Menaion version suppresses much of this ambiguity. I will demonstrate this by exploring three aspects of Anastasia's gendered characterisation in the texts: 1) designations for her throughout each narrative; 2) her identification as a eunuch; and 3) the degree of agency attributed to her. I conclude by offering some thoughts about how alterity theory can help account for these different representations, which I argue are responses to the perceived alterity of the saint.

KW - Vita Anastasiae

KW - Life of Anastasia

KW - cross-dressing

KW - monasticism

KW - late antiquity

KW - gender

KW - eunuch

KW - saint

KW - Menaion

KW - Hagiography

KW - Vita Danielis

KW - Egyptian monasticism

KW - sexuality and gender

KW - alterity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85043761678&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 13

SP - 19

EP - 46

JO - Journal of the Australian Early Medieval Association

JF - Journal of the Australian Early Medieval Association

SN - 1449-9320

ER -