Evidence of impaired compliance and regulation in IFRS-based financial reporting

Tyrone Carlin, Nigel Finch

Research output: Contribution to journalConference paperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The transition to IFRS based reporting has resulted in fundamental departures from many of the long accepted norms embedded in indigenous GAAP systems now superseded in IFRS adopting jurisdictions. The rules relating to goodwill accounting, measurement and reporting represent an excellent case in point, the traditionally dominant capitalise and amortise regime having been disposed of in favour of an impairment testing regime pursuant to which periodic amortisation charges are no longer required. There has been much criticism of this new impairment testing regime, principally along the lines that it results in an increased potential for opportunism in financial statement preparation due to the subjective and unverifiable nature of a range of judgements necessary to the execution of the impairment testing process. In this paper, we add to the extant literature’s catalogue of concerns by documenting systematic non compliance with the disclosure requirements of AASB 136 – Impairment of Assets. We argue that a key problem resulting from this phenomenon is a decline in financial statement comparability. At the policy level, we raise questions as to the implications of the complexity of the IFRS based impairment testing regime both from the preparer and audit perspective.
LanguageEnglish
Pages392-410
Number of pages19
JournalGlobal Conference on Business and Finance proceedings
Volume4
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2009
EventGlobal Conference on Business and Finance - Atlantic City, NJ
Duration: 6 Jan 20099 Jan 2009

Fingerprint

Impairment
International Financial Reporting Standards
Financial reporting
Testing
Financial statements
Jurisdiction
Preparation
Assets
Charge
Noncompliance
Opportunism
Goodwill accounting
Audit
Criticism
Disclosure requirements

Keywords

  • goodwill
  • impairment
  • financial reporting
  • creative accounting

Cite this

@article{56181e43e41e4d39aea9a72c6d1badd0,
title = "Evidence of impaired compliance and regulation in IFRS-based financial reporting",
abstract = "The transition to IFRS based reporting has resulted in fundamental departures from many of the long accepted norms embedded in indigenous GAAP systems now superseded in IFRS adopting jurisdictions. The rules relating to goodwill accounting, measurement and reporting represent an excellent case in point, the traditionally dominant capitalise and amortise regime having been disposed of in favour of an impairment testing regime pursuant to which periodic amortisation charges are no longer required. There has been much criticism of this new impairment testing regime, principally along the lines that it results in an increased potential for opportunism in financial statement preparation due to the subjective and unverifiable nature of a range of judgements necessary to the execution of the impairment testing process. In this paper, we add to the extant literature’s catalogue of concerns by documenting systematic non compliance with the disclosure requirements of AASB 136 – Impairment of Assets. We argue that a key problem resulting from this phenomenon is a decline in financial statement comparability. At the policy level, we raise questions as to the implications of the complexity of the IFRS based impairment testing regime both from the preparer and audit perspective.",
keywords = "goodwill, impairment, financial reporting, creative accounting",
author = "Tyrone Carlin and Nigel Finch",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "392--410",
journal = "Global Conference on Business and Finance proceedings",
issn = "1931-0285",
publisher = "The Institute for Business and Finance",
number = "1",

}

Evidence of impaired compliance and regulation in IFRS-based financial reporting. / Carlin, Tyrone; Finch, Nigel.

In: Global Conference on Business and Finance proceedings, Vol. 4, No. 1, 2009, p. 392-410.

Research output: Contribution to journalConference paperResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evidence of impaired compliance and regulation in IFRS-based financial reporting

AU - Carlin, Tyrone

AU - Finch, Nigel

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - The transition to IFRS based reporting has resulted in fundamental departures from many of the long accepted norms embedded in indigenous GAAP systems now superseded in IFRS adopting jurisdictions. The rules relating to goodwill accounting, measurement and reporting represent an excellent case in point, the traditionally dominant capitalise and amortise regime having been disposed of in favour of an impairment testing regime pursuant to which periodic amortisation charges are no longer required. There has been much criticism of this new impairment testing regime, principally along the lines that it results in an increased potential for opportunism in financial statement preparation due to the subjective and unverifiable nature of a range of judgements necessary to the execution of the impairment testing process. In this paper, we add to the extant literature’s catalogue of concerns by documenting systematic non compliance with the disclosure requirements of AASB 136 – Impairment of Assets. We argue that a key problem resulting from this phenomenon is a decline in financial statement comparability. At the policy level, we raise questions as to the implications of the complexity of the IFRS based impairment testing regime both from the preparer and audit perspective.

AB - The transition to IFRS based reporting has resulted in fundamental departures from many of the long accepted norms embedded in indigenous GAAP systems now superseded in IFRS adopting jurisdictions. The rules relating to goodwill accounting, measurement and reporting represent an excellent case in point, the traditionally dominant capitalise and amortise regime having been disposed of in favour of an impairment testing regime pursuant to which periodic amortisation charges are no longer required. There has been much criticism of this new impairment testing regime, principally along the lines that it results in an increased potential for opportunism in financial statement preparation due to the subjective and unverifiable nature of a range of judgements necessary to the execution of the impairment testing process. In this paper, we add to the extant literature’s catalogue of concerns by documenting systematic non compliance with the disclosure requirements of AASB 136 – Impairment of Assets. We argue that a key problem resulting from this phenomenon is a decline in financial statement comparability. At the policy level, we raise questions as to the implications of the complexity of the IFRS based impairment testing regime both from the preparer and audit perspective.

KW - goodwill

KW - impairment

KW - financial reporting

KW - creative accounting

M3 - Conference paper

VL - 4

SP - 392

EP - 410

JO - Global Conference on Business and Finance proceedings

T2 - Global Conference on Business and Finance proceedings

JF - Global Conference on Business and Finance proceedings

SN - 1931-0285

IS - 1

ER -