Evolution of displays in Galápagos lava lizards: comparative analyses of signallers and robot playbacks to receivers

David L. Clark, Joseph M. Macedonia, John W. Rowe, Mark A. Stuart, Darrell J. Kemp, Terry J. Ord

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Differentiation in the structure of animal signals and displays among closely related species has intrigued biologists for centuries. Such divergence is often attributed to behavioural premating isolation, where sexual selection has favoured species recognition in environments containing sympatric congeners. However, in some cases closely related taxa have undergone speciation and display differentiation in isolation, in the apparent absence of benefits afforded by species recognition. Such is the case for the lava lizards (Microlophus spp.) endemic to the Galápagos Islands, where no two species overlap in distribution and all are thought to have evolved in allopatry from congeners. To test alternative evolutionary models, we used several phylogenetic comparative methods to assess how Microlophus displays have evolved. Results showed some potential for the influence of genetic drift, but little evidence of sexual selection (via male-male competition) or colonization history on the way displays have diverged among taxa. We then used lizard robots to test whether two representative Galápagos lava lizard species, Microlophus grayii and Microlophus indefatigabilis, would respond preferentially to a robot performing conspecific displays over those of the congener. We predicted that, in the absence of reinforcing selection, neither species would show a preference for conspecific displays. Results were mixed: whereas M. grayii showed no discrimination of conspecific over heterospecific displays, male M. indefatigabilis showed significantly stronger responses to their own displays than to those of the heterospecific. We then conducted the same experiment with a mainland congener, Microlophus occipitalis, to provide a broader view of potential responses across the group. Results revealed significant discrimination against heterospecific displays. We discuss our findings in light of hypotheses of signal differentiation, and suggest alternative interpretations for recognition of conspecific displays in species that are thought to have evolved in isolation.

LanguageEnglish
Pages33-44
Number of pages12
JournalAnimal Behaviour
Volume109
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2015

Fingerprint

lava
robots
lizard
lizards
sexual selection
Galapagos Islands
allopatry
genetic drift
biologists
biogeography
testing
history
phylogeny
animals
colonization
divergence
phylogenetics

Keywords

  • communication
  • Galapagos Islands
  • lizard robot
  • Microlophus
  • push-up display
  • sexual selection
  • speciation

Cite this

Clark, David L. ; Macedonia, Joseph M. ; Rowe, John W. ; Stuart, Mark A. ; Kemp, Darrell J. ; Ord, Terry J. / Evolution of displays in Galápagos lava lizards : comparative analyses of signallers and robot playbacks to receivers. In: Animal Behaviour. 2015 ; Vol. 109. pp. 33-44.
@article{1e668c61ed60407bad3cc42db7ddac89,
title = "Evolution of displays in Gal{\'a}pagos lava lizards: comparative analyses of signallers and robot playbacks to receivers",
abstract = "Differentiation in the structure of animal signals and displays among closely related species has intrigued biologists for centuries. Such divergence is often attributed to behavioural premating isolation, where sexual selection has favoured species recognition in environments containing sympatric congeners. However, in some cases closely related taxa have undergone speciation and display differentiation in isolation, in the apparent absence of benefits afforded by species recognition. Such is the case for the lava lizards (Microlophus spp.) endemic to the Gal{\'a}pagos Islands, where no two species overlap in distribution and all are thought to have evolved in allopatry from congeners. To test alternative evolutionary models, we used several phylogenetic comparative methods to assess how Microlophus displays have evolved. Results showed some potential for the influence of genetic drift, but little evidence of sexual selection (via male-male competition) or colonization history on the way displays have diverged among taxa. We then used lizard robots to test whether two representative Gal{\'a}pagos lava lizard species, Microlophus grayii and Microlophus indefatigabilis, would respond preferentially to a robot performing conspecific displays over those of the congener. We predicted that, in the absence of reinforcing selection, neither species would show a preference for conspecific displays. Results were mixed: whereas M. grayii showed no discrimination of conspecific over heterospecific displays, male M. indefatigabilis showed significantly stronger responses to their own displays than to those of the heterospecific. We then conducted the same experiment with a mainland congener, Microlophus occipitalis, to provide a broader view of potential responses across the group. Results revealed significant discrimination against heterospecific displays. We discuss our findings in light of hypotheses of signal differentiation, and suggest alternative interpretations for recognition of conspecific displays in species that are thought to have evolved in isolation.",
keywords = "communication, Galapagos Islands, lizard robot, Microlophus, push-up display, sexual selection, speciation",
author = "Clark, {David L.} and Macedonia, {Joseph M.} and Rowe, {John W.} and Stuart, {Mark A.} and Kemp, {Darrell J.} and Ord, {Terry J.}",
year = "2015",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1016/j.anbehav.2015.08.002",
language = "English",
volume = "109",
pages = "33--44",
journal = "Animal Behaviour",
issn = "0003-3472",
publisher = "ACADEMIC PRESS LTD- ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD",

}

Evolution of displays in Galápagos lava lizards : comparative analyses of signallers and robot playbacks to receivers. / Clark, David L.; Macedonia, Joseph M.; Rowe, John W.; Stuart, Mark A.; Kemp, Darrell J.; Ord, Terry J.

In: Animal Behaviour, Vol. 109, 11.2015, p. 33-44.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evolution of displays in Galápagos lava lizards

T2 - Animal Behaviour

AU - Clark, David L.

AU - Macedonia, Joseph M.

AU - Rowe, John W.

AU - Stuart, Mark A.

AU - Kemp, Darrell J.

AU - Ord, Terry J.

PY - 2015/11

Y1 - 2015/11

N2 - Differentiation in the structure of animal signals and displays among closely related species has intrigued biologists for centuries. Such divergence is often attributed to behavioural premating isolation, where sexual selection has favoured species recognition in environments containing sympatric congeners. However, in some cases closely related taxa have undergone speciation and display differentiation in isolation, in the apparent absence of benefits afforded by species recognition. Such is the case for the lava lizards (Microlophus spp.) endemic to the Galápagos Islands, where no two species overlap in distribution and all are thought to have evolved in allopatry from congeners. To test alternative evolutionary models, we used several phylogenetic comparative methods to assess how Microlophus displays have evolved. Results showed some potential for the influence of genetic drift, but little evidence of sexual selection (via male-male competition) or colonization history on the way displays have diverged among taxa. We then used lizard robots to test whether two representative Galápagos lava lizard species, Microlophus grayii and Microlophus indefatigabilis, would respond preferentially to a robot performing conspecific displays over those of the congener. We predicted that, in the absence of reinforcing selection, neither species would show a preference for conspecific displays. Results were mixed: whereas M. grayii showed no discrimination of conspecific over heterospecific displays, male M. indefatigabilis showed significantly stronger responses to their own displays than to those of the heterospecific. We then conducted the same experiment with a mainland congener, Microlophus occipitalis, to provide a broader view of potential responses across the group. Results revealed significant discrimination against heterospecific displays. We discuss our findings in light of hypotheses of signal differentiation, and suggest alternative interpretations for recognition of conspecific displays in species that are thought to have evolved in isolation.

AB - Differentiation in the structure of animal signals and displays among closely related species has intrigued biologists for centuries. Such divergence is often attributed to behavioural premating isolation, where sexual selection has favoured species recognition in environments containing sympatric congeners. However, in some cases closely related taxa have undergone speciation and display differentiation in isolation, in the apparent absence of benefits afforded by species recognition. Such is the case for the lava lizards (Microlophus spp.) endemic to the Galápagos Islands, where no two species overlap in distribution and all are thought to have evolved in allopatry from congeners. To test alternative evolutionary models, we used several phylogenetic comparative methods to assess how Microlophus displays have evolved. Results showed some potential for the influence of genetic drift, but little evidence of sexual selection (via male-male competition) or colonization history on the way displays have diverged among taxa. We then used lizard robots to test whether two representative Galápagos lava lizard species, Microlophus grayii and Microlophus indefatigabilis, would respond preferentially to a robot performing conspecific displays over those of the congener. We predicted that, in the absence of reinforcing selection, neither species would show a preference for conspecific displays. Results were mixed: whereas M. grayii showed no discrimination of conspecific over heterospecific displays, male M. indefatigabilis showed significantly stronger responses to their own displays than to those of the heterospecific. We then conducted the same experiment with a mainland congener, Microlophus occipitalis, to provide a broader view of potential responses across the group. Results revealed significant discrimination against heterospecific displays. We discuss our findings in light of hypotheses of signal differentiation, and suggest alternative interpretations for recognition of conspecific displays in species that are thought to have evolved in isolation.

KW - communication

KW - Galapagos Islands

KW - lizard robot

KW - Microlophus

KW - push-up display

KW - sexual selection

KW - speciation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84941055076&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.anbehav.2015.08.002

DO - 10.1016/j.anbehav.2015.08.002

M3 - Article

VL - 109

SP - 33

EP - 44

JO - Animal Behaviour

JF - Animal Behaviour

SN - 0003-3472

ER -