Fitness to stand trial in one Australian jurisdiction

the role of cognitive abilities, neurological dysfunction and psychiatric disorders

Amanda Jane White*, Jennifer Batchelor, Susanne Meares, Susan Pulman, Dan Howard

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In Australia, limited research of the factors determining fitness to stand trial (FST) has been conducted. In particular, the relevance of cognitive abilities and neurological dysfunction in accordance with the legal standard of R v. Presser (1958) has not been comprehensively explored. In the largest known sample of court-determined FST cases in Australia examined to date, expert reports for 153 unfit and 91 fit defendants in New South Wales (NSW) over a five-year period were retrospectively reviewed. Data related to cognitive assessment, psychiatric disorders, neurological dysfunction, demographic factors and expert opinion were extracted. The results showed that cognitive abilities, in particular verbal memory, nonverbal skills, and executive functioning, were influential in differentiating between fit and unfit groups and determining FST. However, quantitative analysis was limited as few reports contained test scores or comprehensive psychometric analysis. Defendants with neurological dysfunction alone or with a dual diagnosis of a psychiatric disorder or intellectual disability were more likely to be found unfit to stand trial. Expert opinion was biased toward the referring agent and psychologists were less likely than psychiatrists to examine all of the relevant legal criteria. Comprehensive cognitive assessment in specific cases and more standardised assessment practices are indicated.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)499-511
Number of pages13
JournalPsychiatry, Psychology and Law
Volume23
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Keywords

  • Cognition
  • Cognitive abilities
  • Cognitive assessment
  • Competency to stand trial
  • Fitness to stand trial
  • Forensic assessment
  • Forensic neuropsychology

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Fitness to stand trial in one Australian jurisdiction: the role of cognitive abilities, neurological dysfunction and psychiatric disorders'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Cite this