Improving conservation outcomes for coral reefs affected by future oil palm development in Papua New Guinea

Vivitskaia J D Tulloch, Christopher J. Brown, Hugh P. Possingham, Stacy D. Jupiter, Joseph M. Maina, Carissa Klein

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Clearing forests for oil palm plantations is a major threat to tropical terrestrial biodiversity, and may potentially have large impacts on downstream marine ecosystems (e.g., coral reefs). However, little is known about the impacts of runoff from oil palm plantations, so it is not clear how oil palm development should be modified to minimize the risk of degrading marine ecosystems, or how marine conservation plans should be modified to account for the impacts of oil palm development. We coupled terrestrial and marine biophysical models to simulate changes in sediment/nutrient composition on reefs as a result of oil palm development in Papua New Guinea, and predicted the response of coral and seagrass ecosystems to different land-use scenarios. The condition of almost 60% of coastal ecosystems were predicted to be substantially degraded (more than a 50% decline from their initial state) after 5 years if all suitable land was converted to oil palm, with only 4% of coastal ecosystems improving in condition as trees matured. We evaluated marine ecosystem condition if the oil palm developments were consistent with global sustainability guidelines and found that there were only slight improvements in ecosystems condition compared to the scenario with complete conversion of forest to oil palm. Substantially reducing the impact of oil palm development on marine ecosystems required limiting new plantings to hill slopes below 15°, a more stringent restriction than currently allowed for in the sustainability guidelines. We evaluated priority marine conservation areas given current land-use and found reef ecosystems in these areas will likely be heavily degraded in the future from runoff. We find that marine conservation plans should be modified to prioritize turbid areas where coral communities may be more tolerant of increased suspended sediment in the water. The approach developed here provides guidelines for modifying marine conservation priorities in areas with oil palm development. Importantly, oil palm development guidelines cannot be truly ecologically sustainable unless they are modified to account for the impacts of oil palm on coastal marine ecosystems.

LanguageEnglish
Pages43-54
Number of pages12
JournalBiological Conservation
Volume203
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2016

Fingerprint

Elaeis guineensis
Papua New Guinea
coral reefs
coral reef
oil
marine ecosystem
ecosystems
ecosystem
corals
reefs
coral
runoff
reef
plantation
plantations
land use
sustainability
topographic slope
seagrass
suspended sediment

Keywords

  • Oil palm sustainability, land-sea planning
  • Land-use change
  • Coral reef degradation
  • Marine protected area
  • Ridge to reef
  • Papua New Guinea
  • Sedimentation
  • Marxan

Cite this

Tulloch, Vivitskaia J D ; Brown, Christopher J. ; Possingham, Hugh P. ; Jupiter, Stacy D. ; Maina, Joseph M. ; Klein, Carissa. / Improving conservation outcomes for coral reefs affected by future oil palm development in Papua New Guinea. In: Biological Conservation. 2016 ; Vol. 203. pp. 43-54.
@article{1ae7d382b25f4efa8238c72f675650be,
title = "Improving conservation outcomes for coral reefs affected by future oil palm development in Papua New Guinea",
abstract = "Clearing forests for oil palm plantations is a major threat to tropical terrestrial biodiversity, and may potentially have large impacts on downstream marine ecosystems (e.g., coral reefs). However, little is known about the impacts of runoff from oil palm plantations, so it is not clear how oil palm development should be modified to minimize the risk of degrading marine ecosystems, or how marine conservation plans should be modified to account for the impacts of oil palm development. We coupled terrestrial and marine biophysical models to simulate changes in sediment/nutrient composition on reefs as a result of oil palm development in Papua New Guinea, and predicted the response of coral and seagrass ecosystems to different land-use scenarios. The condition of almost 60{\%} of coastal ecosystems were predicted to be substantially degraded (more than a 50{\%} decline from their initial state) after 5 years if all suitable land was converted to oil palm, with only 4{\%} of coastal ecosystems improving in condition as trees matured. We evaluated marine ecosystem condition if the oil palm developments were consistent with global sustainability guidelines and found that there were only slight improvements in ecosystems condition compared to the scenario with complete conversion of forest to oil palm. Substantially reducing the impact of oil palm development on marine ecosystems required limiting new plantings to hill slopes below 15°, a more stringent restriction than currently allowed for in the sustainability guidelines. We evaluated priority marine conservation areas given current land-use and found reef ecosystems in these areas will likely be heavily degraded in the future from runoff. We find that marine conservation plans should be modified to prioritize turbid areas where coral communities may be more tolerant of increased suspended sediment in the water. The approach developed here provides guidelines for modifying marine conservation priorities in areas with oil palm development. Importantly, oil palm development guidelines cannot be truly ecologically sustainable unless they are modified to account for the impacts of oil palm on coastal marine ecosystems.",
keywords = "Oil palm sustainability, land-sea planning, Land-use change, Coral reef degradation, Marine protected area, Ridge to reef, Papua New Guinea, Sedimentation, Marxan",
author = "Tulloch, {Vivitskaia J D} and Brown, {Christopher J.} and Possingham, {Hugh P.} and Jupiter, {Stacy D.} and Maina, {Joseph M.} and Carissa Klein",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.biocon.2016.08.013",
language = "English",
volume = "203",
pages = "43--54",
journal = "Biological Conservation",
issn = "0006-3207",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Improving conservation outcomes for coral reefs affected by future oil palm development in Papua New Guinea. / Tulloch, Vivitskaia J D; Brown, Christopher J.; Possingham, Hugh P.; Jupiter, Stacy D.; Maina, Joseph M.; Klein, Carissa.

In: Biological Conservation, Vol. 203, 01.11.2016, p. 43-54.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Improving conservation outcomes for coral reefs affected by future oil palm development in Papua New Guinea

AU - Tulloch, Vivitskaia J D

AU - Brown, Christopher J.

AU - Possingham, Hugh P.

AU - Jupiter, Stacy D.

AU - Maina, Joseph M.

AU - Klein, Carissa

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - Clearing forests for oil palm plantations is a major threat to tropical terrestrial biodiversity, and may potentially have large impacts on downstream marine ecosystems (e.g., coral reefs). However, little is known about the impacts of runoff from oil palm plantations, so it is not clear how oil palm development should be modified to minimize the risk of degrading marine ecosystems, or how marine conservation plans should be modified to account for the impacts of oil palm development. We coupled terrestrial and marine biophysical models to simulate changes in sediment/nutrient composition on reefs as a result of oil palm development in Papua New Guinea, and predicted the response of coral and seagrass ecosystems to different land-use scenarios. The condition of almost 60% of coastal ecosystems were predicted to be substantially degraded (more than a 50% decline from their initial state) after 5 years if all suitable land was converted to oil palm, with only 4% of coastal ecosystems improving in condition as trees matured. We evaluated marine ecosystem condition if the oil palm developments were consistent with global sustainability guidelines and found that there were only slight improvements in ecosystems condition compared to the scenario with complete conversion of forest to oil palm. Substantially reducing the impact of oil palm development on marine ecosystems required limiting new plantings to hill slopes below 15°, a more stringent restriction than currently allowed for in the sustainability guidelines. We evaluated priority marine conservation areas given current land-use and found reef ecosystems in these areas will likely be heavily degraded in the future from runoff. We find that marine conservation plans should be modified to prioritize turbid areas where coral communities may be more tolerant of increased suspended sediment in the water. The approach developed here provides guidelines for modifying marine conservation priorities in areas with oil palm development. Importantly, oil palm development guidelines cannot be truly ecologically sustainable unless they are modified to account for the impacts of oil palm on coastal marine ecosystems.

AB - Clearing forests for oil palm plantations is a major threat to tropical terrestrial biodiversity, and may potentially have large impacts on downstream marine ecosystems (e.g., coral reefs). However, little is known about the impacts of runoff from oil palm plantations, so it is not clear how oil palm development should be modified to minimize the risk of degrading marine ecosystems, or how marine conservation plans should be modified to account for the impacts of oil palm development. We coupled terrestrial and marine biophysical models to simulate changes in sediment/nutrient composition on reefs as a result of oil palm development in Papua New Guinea, and predicted the response of coral and seagrass ecosystems to different land-use scenarios. The condition of almost 60% of coastal ecosystems were predicted to be substantially degraded (more than a 50% decline from their initial state) after 5 years if all suitable land was converted to oil palm, with only 4% of coastal ecosystems improving in condition as trees matured. We evaluated marine ecosystem condition if the oil palm developments were consistent with global sustainability guidelines and found that there were only slight improvements in ecosystems condition compared to the scenario with complete conversion of forest to oil palm. Substantially reducing the impact of oil palm development on marine ecosystems required limiting new plantings to hill slopes below 15°, a more stringent restriction than currently allowed for in the sustainability guidelines. We evaluated priority marine conservation areas given current land-use and found reef ecosystems in these areas will likely be heavily degraded in the future from runoff. We find that marine conservation plans should be modified to prioritize turbid areas where coral communities may be more tolerant of increased suspended sediment in the water. The approach developed here provides guidelines for modifying marine conservation priorities in areas with oil palm development. Importantly, oil palm development guidelines cannot be truly ecologically sustainable unless they are modified to account for the impacts of oil palm on coastal marine ecosystems.

KW - Oil palm sustainability, land-sea planning

KW - Land-use change

KW - Coral reef degradation

KW - Marine protected area

KW - Ridge to reef

KW - Papua New Guinea

KW - Sedimentation

KW - Marxan

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84986880487&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.biocon.2016.08.013

DO - 10.1016/j.biocon.2016.08.013

M3 - Article

VL - 203

SP - 43

EP - 54

JO - Biological Conservation

T2 - Biological Conservation

JF - Biological Conservation

SN - 0006-3207

ER -