International performance appraisal: policies, practices and processes in Australian subsidiaries of healthcare MNCs

Jane Maley, Robin Kramar

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Difficulties in executing performance appraisals are widely reported. However, little is known about the conduct of performance appraisals for host country managers. These managers are usually isolated from their supervisors, and it could, therefore, be expected that they would also experience difficulties in the conduct of their performance appraisal. This paper examines the extent, nature and limitations of performance appraisals for host country managers in a sector of the healthcare industry in Australia. The study found performance appraisals are widely used, but in most cases are done poorly. In over 80 per cent of cases the appraisals were perceived as ineffective, which is higher than world wide reactions to appraisal. The performance appraisal process was found to be influenced by the emphasis given to the bottom line, the relationship with the supervisor and the effect of the multinational’s parent strategy, structure and nationality. The findings suggest that the host country manager’s experience of the appraisal often results in the manager perceiving limited opportunities for career development and advancement in the company. This may impact on the overall long term performance of the subsidiary. It is recommended that some straightforward modifications to the appraisal could make a significant contribution to both the retention and development of these managers, and, therefore, to company performance.
LanguageEnglish
Pages21-41
Number of pages21
JournalResearch and practice in human resource management
Volume15
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2007

Fingerprint

Subsidiaries
International performance
Performance appraisal
Healthcare
Managers
Host country
Supervisors
Nationality
Long-term performance
Career development
Multinationals
Career advancement
Nature
Industry
Company performance

Cite this

@article{51cc5bf95c3f40b1ac0a990ad5826aff,
title = "International performance appraisal: policies, practices and processes in Australian subsidiaries of healthcare MNCs",
abstract = "Difficulties in executing performance appraisals are widely reported. However, little is known about the conduct of performance appraisals for host country managers. These managers are usually isolated from their supervisors, and it could, therefore, be expected that they would also experience difficulties in the conduct of their performance appraisal. This paper examines the extent, nature and limitations of performance appraisals for host country managers in a sector of the healthcare industry in Australia. The study found performance appraisals are widely used, but in most cases are done poorly. In over 80 per cent of cases the appraisals were perceived as ineffective, which is higher than world wide reactions to appraisal. The performance appraisal process was found to be influenced by the emphasis given to the bottom line, the relationship with the supervisor and the effect of the multinational’s parent strategy, structure and nationality. The findings suggest that the host country manager’s experience of the appraisal often results in the manager perceiving limited opportunities for career development and advancement in the company. This may impact on the overall long term performance of the subsidiary. It is recommended that some straightforward modifications to the appraisal could make a significant contribution to both the retention and development of these managers, and, therefore, to company performance.",
author = "Jane Maley and Robin Kramar",
year = "2007",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
pages = "21--41",
journal = "Research and practice in human resource management",
issn = "0218-5180",
publisher = "School of Management, Curtin University of Technology and the Singapore Human Resources Institute (SHRI)",
number = "2",

}

International performance appraisal : policies, practices and processes in Australian subsidiaries of healthcare MNCs. / Maley, Jane; Kramar, Robin.

In: Research and practice in human resource management, Vol. 15, No. 2, 2007, p. 21-41.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - International performance appraisal

T2 - Research and practice in human resource management

AU - Maley, Jane

AU - Kramar, Robin

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - Difficulties in executing performance appraisals are widely reported. However, little is known about the conduct of performance appraisals for host country managers. These managers are usually isolated from their supervisors, and it could, therefore, be expected that they would also experience difficulties in the conduct of their performance appraisal. This paper examines the extent, nature and limitations of performance appraisals for host country managers in a sector of the healthcare industry in Australia. The study found performance appraisals are widely used, but in most cases are done poorly. In over 80 per cent of cases the appraisals were perceived as ineffective, which is higher than world wide reactions to appraisal. The performance appraisal process was found to be influenced by the emphasis given to the bottom line, the relationship with the supervisor and the effect of the multinational’s parent strategy, structure and nationality. The findings suggest that the host country manager’s experience of the appraisal often results in the manager perceiving limited opportunities for career development and advancement in the company. This may impact on the overall long term performance of the subsidiary. It is recommended that some straightforward modifications to the appraisal could make a significant contribution to both the retention and development of these managers, and, therefore, to company performance.

AB - Difficulties in executing performance appraisals are widely reported. However, little is known about the conduct of performance appraisals for host country managers. These managers are usually isolated from their supervisors, and it could, therefore, be expected that they would also experience difficulties in the conduct of their performance appraisal. This paper examines the extent, nature and limitations of performance appraisals for host country managers in a sector of the healthcare industry in Australia. The study found performance appraisals are widely used, but in most cases are done poorly. In over 80 per cent of cases the appraisals were perceived as ineffective, which is higher than world wide reactions to appraisal. The performance appraisal process was found to be influenced by the emphasis given to the bottom line, the relationship with the supervisor and the effect of the multinational’s parent strategy, structure and nationality. The findings suggest that the host country manager’s experience of the appraisal often results in the manager perceiving limited opportunities for career development and advancement in the company. This may impact on the overall long term performance of the subsidiary. It is recommended that some straightforward modifications to the appraisal could make a significant contribution to both the retention and development of these managers, and, therefore, to company performance.

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 21

EP - 41

JO - Research and practice in human resource management

JF - Research and practice in human resource management

SN - 0218-5180

IS - 2

ER -