Letty Garth's little red book: "Rumpelstiltskin", realism, and Middlemarch

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Letty Garth's favourite red volume makes its appearance in Middlemarch at the beginning of Book 7, at the Vincy's New Year's Day party that draws most of the Middlemarch town characters together. It is a small passage that can easily go unnoticed - or, if registered at all, glossed as simply part of the fabric of dense, inconsequential details that realist texts deploy to produce verisimilitude. Roland Barthes describes such details as potentially scandalous from the point of view of structure in that they seem to amount to a kind of narrative luxury, likely to threaten structural coherence, recoverable at best as filling or as giving some index of character or atmosphere. Such details might be said to reinforce the vices of nineteenth-century realism, including closing the gap between words and things: we are the real, these details say, producing the referential illusion. They amount to bad narrative housekeeping, increasing the cost of narrative information. Since the detail of Letty's book involves a young child it is doubly likely, in a novel so clearly dedicated to the adult world of compromise and doubtful success, to be set aside as mere local colour. The potentially trivializing function of the paradox of small instances of excess is reflected in Barthes' descriptive phrases for them: useless details, insignificant notation.

LanguageEnglish
Pages549-568
Number of pages20
JournalVictorian Literature and Culture
Volume45
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2017

Fingerprint

realism
narrative
housekeeping
luxury
compromise
nineteenth century
town
costs
Realism
Middlemarch
Red Book
Roland Barthes
coherence
Costs
Local Colour
Illusion
Realist
Excess
Compromise
Verisimilitude

Cite this

@article{1d041e650d43419ca1ab2a0c5a919d2c,
title = "Letty Garth's little red book: {"}Rumpelstiltskin{"}, realism, and Middlemarch",
abstract = "Letty Garth's favourite red volume makes its appearance in Middlemarch at the beginning of Book 7, at the Vincy's New Year's Day party that draws most of the Middlemarch town characters together. It is a small passage that can easily go unnoticed - or, if registered at all, glossed as simply part of the fabric of dense, inconsequential details that realist texts deploy to produce verisimilitude. Roland Barthes describes such details as potentially scandalous from the point of view of structure in that they seem to amount to a kind of narrative luxury, likely to threaten structural coherence, recoverable at best as filling or as giving some index of character or atmosphere. Such details might be said to reinforce the vices of nineteenth-century realism, including closing the gap between words and things: we are the real, these details say, producing the referential illusion. They amount to bad narrative housekeeping, increasing the cost of narrative information. Since the detail of Letty's book involves a young child it is doubly likely, in a novel so clearly dedicated to the adult world of compromise and doubtful success, to be set aside as mere local colour. The potentially trivializing function of the paradox of small instances of excess is reflected in Barthes' descriptive phrases for them: useless details, insignificant notation.",
author = "Lee O'Brien",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1017/S1060150317000109",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "549--568",
journal = "Victorian Literature and Culture",
issn = "1060-1503",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "3",

}

Letty Garth's little red book : "Rumpelstiltskin", realism, and Middlemarch. / O'Brien, Lee.

In: Victorian Literature and Culture, Vol. 45, No. 3, 01.09.2017, p. 549-568.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Letty Garth's little red book

T2 - Victorian Literature and Culture

AU - O'Brien, Lee

PY - 2017/9/1

Y1 - 2017/9/1

N2 - Letty Garth's favourite red volume makes its appearance in Middlemarch at the beginning of Book 7, at the Vincy's New Year's Day party that draws most of the Middlemarch town characters together. It is a small passage that can easily go unnoticed - or, if registered at all, glossed as simply part of the fabric of dense, inconsequential details that realist texts deploy to produce verisimilitude. Roland Barthes describes such details as potentially scandalous from the point of view of structure in that they seem to amount to a kind of narrative luxury, likely to threaten structural coherence, recoverable at best as filling or as giving some index of character or atmosphere. Such details might be said to reinforce the vices of nineteenth-century realism, including closing the gap between words and things: we are the real, these details say, producing the referential illusion. They amount to bad narrative housekeeping, increasing the cost of narrative information. Since the detail of Letty's book involves a young child it is doubly likely, in a novel so clearly dedicated to the adult world of compromise and doubtful success, to be set aside as mere local colour. The potentially trivializing function of the paradox of small instances of excess is reflected in Barthes' descriptive phrases for them: useless details, insignificant notation.

AB - Letty Garth's favourite red volume makes its appearance in Middlemarch at the beginning of Book 7, at the Vincy's New Year's Day party that draws most of the Middlemarch town characters together. It is a small passage that can easily go unnoticed - or, if registered at all, glossed as simply part of the fabric of dense, inconsequential details that realist texts deploy to produce verisimilitude. Roland Barthes describes such details as potentially scandalous from the point of view of structure in that they seem to amount to a kind of narrative luxury, likely to threaten structural coherence, recoverable at best as filling or as giving some index of character or atmosphere. Such details might be said to reinforce the vices of nineteenth-century realism, including closing the gap between words and things: we are the real, these details say, producing the referential illusion. They amount to bad narrative housekeeping, increasing the cost of narrative information. Since the detail of Letty's book involves a young child it is doubly likely, in a novel so clearly dedicated to the adult world of compromise and doubtful success, to be set aside as mere local colour. The potentially trivializing function of the paradox of small instances of excess is reflected in Barthes' descriptive phrases for them: useless details, insignificant notation.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85028817706&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S1060150317000109

DO - 10.1017/S1060150317000109

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 549

EP - 568

JO - Victorian Literature and Culture

JF - Victorian Literature and Culture

SN - 1060-1503

IS - 3

ER -