Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research

Angela Ballantyne, Wendy A Rogers

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Pregnant women and their foetuses have long been regarded as vulnerable, where being vulnerable indicates a likelihood of suffering harm. This perception has led to the widespread exclusion of pregnant women from clinical research, in order to protect foetuses and the women who carry them from any dangers associated with exposure to experimental therapeutic products or interventions. This chapter explores the ways in which pregnant women are vulnerable, and the potential risk of exploitation if pregnant women are enrolled in clinical research. There are three overlapping sources of vulnerability: inherent, situational, and pathogenic, and each of these may be dispositional (i.e. potential) or occurrent (i.e. requiring immediate action to limit harm). We argue that while pregnant women may experience one or more forms of vulnerability, in general they are not at risk of exploitation during research because they do not provide researchers with the opportunity to conduct more efficient research. We conclude with policy suggestions for conducting research with pregnant women that responds to vulnerability, promotes autonomy, and supports fair access to research participation. We focus on pregnancy registries, parental consent, and minimal risk research limits.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationClinical Research Involving Pregnant Women
EditorsFrancoise Baylis, Angela Ballantyne
Place of PublicationSwitzerland
PublisherSpringer, Springer Nature
Pages139-159
Number of pages21
ISBN (Electronic)9783319265124
ISBN (Print)9783319265100
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Publication series

NameResearch ethics forum
PublisherSpringer
Volume3
ISSN (Print)2212-9529
ISSN (Electronic)2212-9537

Fingerprint

pregnancy
exploitation
vulnerability
risk research
exclusion
autonomy
participation
experience

Cite this

Ballantyne, A., & Rogers, W. A. (2016). Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research. In F. Baylis, & A. Ballantyne (Eds.), Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women (pp. 139-159). (Research ethics forum; Vol. 3). Switzerland: Springer, Springer Nature. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-26512-4_8
Ballantyne, Angela ; Rogers, Wendy A. / Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research. Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women. editor / Francoise Baylis ; Angela Ballantyne. Switzerland : Springer, Springer Nature, 2016. pp. 139-159 (Research ethics forum).
@inbook{f3cae672932f44e79b29d425a309305d,
title = "Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research",
abstract = "Pregnant women and their foetuses have long been regarded as vulnerable, where being vulnerable indicates a likelihood of suffering harm. This perception has led to the widespread exclusion of pregnant women from clinical research, in order to protect foetuses and the women who carry them from any dangers associated with exposure to experimental therapeutic products or interventions. This chapter explores the ways in which pregnant women are vulnerable, and the potential risk of exploitation if pregnant women are enrolled in clinical research. There are three overlapping sources of vulnerability: inherent, situational, and pathogenic, and each of these may be dispositional (i.e. potential) or occurrent (i.e. requiring immediate action to limit harm). We argue that while pregnant women may experience one or more forms of vulnerability, in general they are not at risk of exploitation during research because they do not provide researchers with the opportunity to conduct more efficient research. We conclude with policy suggestions for conducting research with pregnant women that responds to vulnerability, promotes autonomy, and supports fair access to research participation. We focus on pregnancy registries, parental consent, and minimal risk research limits.",
author = "Angela Ballantyne and Rogers, {Wendy A}",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1007/978-3-319-26512-4_8",
language = "English",
isbn = "9783319265100",
series = "Research ethics forum",
publisher = "Springer, Springer Nature",
pages = "139--159",
editor = "Francoise Baylis and Angela Ballantyne",
booktitle = "Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women",
address = "United States",

}

Ballantyne, A & Rogers, WA 2016, Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research. in F Baylis & A Ballantyne (eds), Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women. Research ethics forum, vol. 3, Springer, Springer Nature, Switzerland, pp. 139-159. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-26512-4_8

Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research. / Ballantyne, Angela; Rogers, Wendy A.

Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women. ed. / Francoise Baylis; Angela Ballantyne. Switzerland : Springer, Springer Nature, 2016. p. 139-159 (Research ethics forum; Vol. 3).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research

AU - Ballantyne, Angela

AU - Rogers, Wendy A

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Pregnant women and their foetuses have long been regarded as vulnerable, where being vulnerable indicates a likelihood of suffering harm. This perception has led to the widespread exclusion of pregnant women from clinical research, in order to protect foetuses and the women who carry them from any dangers associated with exposure to experimental therapeutic products or interventions. This chapter explores the ways in which pregnant women are vulnerable, and the potential risk of exploitation if pregnant women are enrolled in clinical research. There are three overlapping sources of vulnerability: inherent, situational, and pathogenic, and each of these may be dispositional (i.e. potential) or occurrent (i.e. requiring immediate action to limit harm). We argue that while pregnant women may experience one or more forms of vulnerability, in general they are not at risk of exploitation during research because they do not provide researchers with the opportunity to conduct more efficient research. We conclude with policy suggestions for conducting research with pregnant women that responds to vulnerability, promotes autonomy, and supports fair access to research participation. We focus on pregnancy registries, parental consent, and minimal risk research limits.

AB - Pregnant women and their foetuses have long been regarded as vulnerable, where being vulnerable indicates a likelihood of suffering harm. This perception has led to the widespread exclusion of pregnant women from clinical research, in order to protect foetuses and the women who carry them from any dangers associated with exposure to experimental therapeutic products or interventions. This chapter explores the ways in which pregnant women are vulnerable, and the potential risk of exploitation if pregnant women are enrolled in clinical research. There are three overlapping sources of vulnerability: inherent, situational, and pathogenic, and each of these may be dispositional (i.e. potential) or occurrent (i.e. requiring immediate action to limit harm). We argue that while pregnant women may experience one or more forms of vulnerability, in general they are not at risk of exploitation during research because they do not provide researchers with the opportunity to conduct more efficient research. We conclude with policy suggestions for conducting research with pregnant women that responds to vulnerability, promotes autonomy, and supports fair access to research participation. We focus on pregnancy registries, parental consent, and minimal risk research limits.

U2 - 10.1007/978-3-319-26512-4_8

DO - 10.1007/978-3-319-26512-4_8

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9783319265100

T3 - Research ethics forum

SP - 139

EP - 159

BT - Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women

A2 - Baylis, Francoise

A2 - Ballantyne, Angela

PB - Springer, Springer Nature

CY - Switzerland

ER -

Ballantyne A, Rogers WA. Pregnancy, vulnerability, and the risk of exploitation in clinical research. In Baylis F, Ballantyne A, editors, Clinical Research Involving Pregnant Women. Switzerland: Springer, Springer Nature. 2016. p. 139-159. (Research ethics forum). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-26512-4_8