Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate

Tim R. McClanahan, Simon D. Donner, Jeffrey A. Maynard, M. Aaron MacNeil, Nicholas A J Graham, Joseph Maina, Andrew C. Baker, Jahson B. Alemu I., Maria Beger, Stuart J. Campbell, Emily S. Darling, C. Mark Eakin, Scott F. Heron, Stacy D. Jupiter, Carolyn J. Lundquist, Elizabeth McLeod, Peter J. Mumby, Michelle J. Paddack, Elizabeth R. Selig, Robert van Woesik

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Managing coral reefs for resilience to climate change is a popular concept but has been difficult to implement because the empirical scientific evidence has either not been evaluated or is sometimes unsupportive of theory, which leads to uncertainty when considering methods and identifying priority reefs. We asked experts and reviewed the scientific literature for guidance on the multiple physical and biological factors that affect the ability of coral reefs to resist and recover from climate disturbance. Eleven key factors to inform decisions based on scaling scientific evidence and the achievability of quantifying the factors were identified. Factors important to resistance and recovery, which are important components of resilience, were not strongly related, and should be assessed independently. The abundance of resistant (heat-tolerant) coral species and past temperature variability were perceived to provide the greatest resistance to climate change, while coral recruitment rates, and macroalgae abundance were most influential in the recovery process. Based on the 11 key factors, we tested an evidence-based framework for climate change resilience in an Indonesian marine protected area. The results suggest our evidence-weighted framework improved upon existing un-weighted methods in terms of characterizing resilience and distinguishing priority sites. The evaluation supports the concept that, despite high ecological complexity, relatively few strong variables can be important in influencing ecosystem dynamics. This is the first rigorous assessment of factors promoting coral reef resilience based on their perceived importance, empirical evidence, and feasibility of measurement. There were few differences between scientists' perceptions of factor importance and the scientific evidence found in journal publications but more before and after impact studies will be required to fully test the validity of all the factors. The methods here will increase the feasibility and defensibility of including key resilience metrics in evaluations of coral reefs, as well as reduce costs. Adaptation, marine protected areas, priority setting, resistance, recovery.

LanguageEnglish
Article numbere42884
Pages1-7
Number of pages7
JournalPLoS ONE
Volume7
Issue number8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 29 Aug 2012

Fingerprint

Coral Reefs
Reefs
Climate
coral reefs
Climate Change
climate change
Anthozoa
Climate change
corals
conservation areas
Recovery
Literature
Seaweed
Biological Factors
Uncertainty
Ecosystem
macroalgae
Publications
reefs
uncertainty

Cite this

McClanahan, T. R., Donner, S. D., Maynard, J. A., MacNeil, M. A., Graham, N. A. J., Maina, J., ... van Woesik, R. (2012). Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate. PLoS ONE, 7(8), 1-7. [e42884]. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0042884
McClanahan, Tim R. ; Donner, Simon D. ; Maynard, Jeffrey A. ; MacNeil, M. Aaron ; Graham, Nicholas A J ; Maina, Joseph ; Baker, Andrew C. ; Alemu I., Jahson B. ; Beger, Maria ; Campbell, Stuart J. ; Darling, Emily S. ; Eakin, C. Mark ; Heron, Scott F. ; Jupiter, Stacy D. ; Lundquist, Carolyn J. ; McLeod, Elizabeth ; Mumby, Peter J. ; Paddack, Michelle J. ; Selig, Elizabeth R. ; van Woesik, Robert. / Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate. In: PLoS ONE. 2012 ; Vol. 7, No. 8. pp. 1-7.
@article{80b9ff56076240bcb4b038da8108d42d,
title = "Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate",
abstract = "Managing coral reefs for resilience to climate change is a popular concept but has been difficult to implement because the empirical scientific evidence has either not been evaluated or is sometimes unsupportive of theory, which leads to uncertainty when considering methods and identifying priority reefs. We asked experts and reviewed the scientific literature for guidance on the multiple physical and biological factors that affect the ability of coral reefs to resist and recover from climate disturbance. Eleven key factors to inform decisions based on scaling scientific evidence and the achievability of quantifying the factors were identified. Factors important to resistance and recovery, which are important components of resilience, were not strongly related, and should be assessed independently. The abundance of resistant (heat-tolerant) coral species and past temperature variability were perceived to provide the greatest resistance to climate change, while coral recruitment rates, and macroalgae abundance were most influential in the recovery process. Based on the 11 key factors, we tested an evidence-based framework for climate change resilience in an Indonesian marine protected area. The results suggest our evidence-weighted framework improved upon existing un-weighted methods in terms of characterizing resilience and distinguishing priority sites. The evaluation supports the concept that, despite high ecological complexity, relatively few strong variables can be important in influencing ecosystem dynamics. This is the first rigorous assessment of factors promoting coral reef resilience based on their perceived importance, empirical evidence, and feasibility of measurement. There were few differences between scientists' perceptions of factor importance and the scientific evidence found in journal publications but more before and after impact studies will be required to fully test the validity of all the factors. The methods here will increase the feasibility and defensibility of including key resilience metrics in evaluations of coral reefs, as well as reduce costs. Adaptation, marine protected areas, priority setting, resistance, recovery.",
author = "McClanahan, {Tim R.} and Donner, {Simon D.} and Maynard, {Jeffrey A.} and MacNeil, {M. Aaron} and Graham, {Nicholas A J} and Joseph Maina and Baker, {Andrew C.} and {Alemu I.}, {Jahson B.} and Maria Beger and Campbell, {Stuart J.} and Darling, {Emily S.} and Eakin, {C. Mark} and Heron, {Scott F.} and Jupiter, {Stacy D.} and Lundquist, {Carolyn J.} and Elizabeth McLeod and Mumby, {Peter J.} and Paddack, {Michelle J.} and Selig, {Elizabeth R.} and {van Woesik}, Robert",
year = "2012",
month = "8",
day = "29",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0042884",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "1--7",
journal = "PLoS ONE",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "8",

}

McClanahan, TR, Donner, SD, Maynard, JA, MacNeil, MA, Graham, NAJ, Maina, J, Baker, AC, Alemu I., JB, Beger, M, Campbell, SJ, Darling, ES, Eakin, CM, Heron, SF, Jupiter, SD, Lundquist, CJ, McLeod, E, Mumby, PJ, Paddack, MJ, Selig, ER & van Woesik, R 2012, 'Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate', PLoS ONE, vol. 7, no. 8, e42884, pp. 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0042884

Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate. / McClanahan, Tim R.; Donner, Simon D.; Maynard, Jeffrey A.; MacNeil, M. Aaron; Graham, Nicholas A J; Maina, Joseph; Baker, Andrew C.; Alemu I., Jahson B.; Beger, Maria; Campbell, Stuart J.; Darling, Emily S.; Eakin, C. Mark; Heron, Scott F.; Jupiter, Stacy D.; Lundquist, Carolyn J.; McLeod, Elizabeth; Mumby, Peter J.; Paddack, Michelle J.; Selig, Elizabeth R.; van Woesik, Robert.

In: PLoS ONE, Vol. 7, No. 8, e42884, 29.08.2012, p. 1-7.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Prioritizing key resilience indicators to support coral reef management in a changing climate

AU - McClanahan, Tim R.

AU - Donner, Simon D.

AU - Maynard, Jeffrey A.

AU - MacNeil, M. Aaron

AU - Graham, Nicholas A J

AU - Maina, Joseph

AU - Baker, Andrew C.

AU - Alemu I., Jahson B.

AU - Beger, Maria

AU - Campbell, Stuart J.

AU - Darling, Emily S.

AU - Eakin, C. Mark

AU - Heron, Scott F.

AU - Jupiter, Stacy D.

AU - Lundquist, Carolyn J.

AU - McLeod, Elizabeth

AU - Mumby, Peter J.

AU - Paddack, Michelle J.

AU - Selig, Elizabeth R.

AU - van Woesik, Robert

PY - 2012/8/29

Y1 - 2012/8/29

N2 - Managing coral reefs for resilience to climate change is a popular concept but has been difficult to implement because the empirical scientific evidence has either not been evaluated or is sometimes unsupportive of theory, which leads to uncertainty when considering methods and identifying priority reefs. We asked experts and reviewed the scientific literature for guidance on the multiple physical and biological factors that affect the ability of coral reefs to resist and recover from climate disturbance. Eleven key factors to inform decisions based on scaling scientific evidence and the achievability of quantifying the factors were identified. Factors important to resistance and recovery, which are important components of resilience, were not strongly related, and should be assessed independently. The abundance of resistant (heat-tolerant) coral species and past temperature variability were perceived to provide the greatest resistance to climate change, while coral recruitment rates, and macroalgae abundance were most influential in the recovery process. Based on the 11 key factors, we tested an evidence-based framework for climate change resilience in an Indonesian marine protected area. The results suggest our evidence-weighted framework improved upon existing un-weighted methods in terms of characterizing resilience and distinguishing priority sites. The evaluation supports the concept that, despite high ecological complexity, relatively few strong variables can be important in influencing ecosystem dynamics. This is the first rigorous assessment of factors promoting coral reef resilience based on their perceived importance, empirical evidence, and feasibility of measurement. There were few differences between scientists' perceptions of factor importance and the scientific evidence found in journal publications but more before and after impact studies will be required to fully test the validity of all the factors. The methods here will increase the feasibility and defensibility of including key resilience metrics in evaluations of coral reefs, as well as reduce costs. Adaptation, marine protected areas, priority setting, resistance, recovery.

AB - Managing coral reefs for resilience to climate change is a popular concept but has been difficult to implement because the empirical scientific evidence has either not been evaluated or is sometimes unsupportive of theory, which leads to uncertainty when considering methods and identifying priority reefs. We asked experts and reviewed the scientific literature for guidance on the multiple physical and biological factors that affect the ability of coral reefs to resist and recover from climate disturbance. Eleven key factors to inform decisions based on scaling scientific evidence and the achievability of quantifying the factors were identified. Factors important to resistance and recovery, which are important components of resilience, were not strongly related, and should be assessed independently. The abundance of resistant (heat-tolerant) coral species and past temperature variability were perceived to provide the greatest resistance to climate change, while coral recruitment rates, and macroalgae abundance were most influential in the recovery process. Based on the 11 key factors, we tested an evidence-based framework for climate change resilience in an Indonesian marine protected area. The results suggest our evidence-weighted framework improved upon existing un-weighted methods in terms of characterizing resilience and distinguishing priority sites. The evaluation supports the concept that, despite high ecological complexity, relatively few strong variables can be important in influencing ecosystem dynamics. This is the first rigorous assessment of factors promoting coral reef resilience based on their perceived importance, empirical evidence, and feasibility of measurement. There were few differences between scientists' perceptions of factor importance and the scientific evidence found in journal publications but more before and after impact studies will be required to fully test the validity of all the factors. The methods here will increase the feasibility and defensibility of including key resilience metrics in evaluations of coral reefs, as well as reduce costs. Adaptation, marine protected areas, priority setting, resistance, recovery.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84865593200&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0042884

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0042884

M3 - Review article

VL - 7

SP - 1

EP - 7

JO - PLoS ONE

T2 - PLoS ONE

JF - PLoS ONE

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 8

M1 - e42884

ER -