Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Relational equality and the debate between externalist and internalist theories of relational autonomy

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Chapter › peer-review

    Abstract

    Internalist theories of relational autonomy specify conditions for autonomy that are wholly internal to agents’ psychologies. Externalist theories claim that internal conditions are insufficient to explain the autonomy-impairing effects of social oppression. Autonomy requires, in addition, equality of socio-relational status. Social relations and social structures characterized by domination, oppression, and status inequality, and that convey messages of disrespect and inferiority, impair the autonomy of individual members of subordinated or marginalized social groups. Externalist theories thus seem to be appealing to relational egalitarian intuitions. However, the debate between internalist and externalist theories of relational autonomy has proceeded without much reference to the literature in normative political philosophy on relational equality. My aim in this chapter is first to show that mapping the conceptual connections between externalist theories and the claims of relational egalitarianism helps to clarify what is at stake in the debate between internalist and externalist theories of relational autonomy. It also helps to clarify the importance of autonomy in relational egalitarian theory. Second, I will argue that by using the conceptual resources of relational egalitarianism, externalist theories are better able to respond to some of the standard objections against them, namely, that they run the risk of disrespecting the agency of persons subject to social oppression and inviting paternalistic interventions into their lives.

    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationAutonomy and equality
    Subtitle of host publicationrelational approaches
    EditorsNatalie Stoljar, Kristin Voigt
    Place of PublicationNew York ; London
    PublisherRoutledge, Taylor and Francis Group
    Chapter2
    Pages32-56
    Number of pages25
    ISBN (Electronic)9780367823344
    ISBN (Print)9780367416898, 9781032122878
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2022

    Publication series

    NameRoutledge Studies in Contemporary Philosophy

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Relational equality and the debate between externalist and internalist theories of relational autonomy'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this