Scalar Implicatures Versus Presuppositions: The View from Acquisition

Cory Bill, Jacopo Romoli, Florian Schwarz, Stephen Crain

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This paper reports an experimental investigation of presuppositions and scalar implicatures in language acquisition. Recent proposals (Chemla 2009; Romoli 2012, Romoli in J Semant 1–47, 2014) posit the same mechanisms for generating both types of inferences, in contrast to the traditional view. We used a Covered Box picture selection task to compare the interpretations assigned by two groups of children (4/5 and 7 year olds) and by adults, in response to sentences with presuppositions and ones with either ‘direct’ or ‘indirect’ scalar implicatures. The main finding was that the behavior of children and adults differed across inference types. This asymmetry is consistent with the traditional perspective, but poses a challenge for the more recent uniform accounts. We discuss how the latter could be amended to account for these findings, and also relate the findings to previous results on presupposition processing. Finally, we discuss an unexpected difference found between direct and indirect scalar implicatures.

LanguageEnglish
Pages57-71
Number of pages15
JournalTopoi
Volume35
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2016

Fingerprint

Scalar Implicatures
Presupposition
Inference
Language Acquisition
Selection Task
Asymmetry

Keywords

  • Child language acquisition
  • Pragmatics
  • Presuppositions
  • Scalar implicatures

Cite this

Bill, Cory ; Romoli, Jacopo ; Schwarz, Florian ; Crain, Stephen. / Scalar Implicatures Versus Presuppositions : The View from Acquisition. In: Topoi. 2016 ; Vol. 35, No. 1. pp. 57-71.
@article{088339a5dc5a4806a1d2f9499a878215,
title = "Scalar Implicatures Versus Presuppositions: The View from Acquisition",
abstract = "This paper reports an experimental investigation of presuppositions and scalar implicatures in language acquisition. Recent proposals (Chemla 2009; Romoli 2012, Romoli in J Semant 1–47, 2014) posit the same mechanisms for generating both types of inferences, in contrast to the traditional view. We used a Covered Box picture selection task to compare the interpretations assigned by two groups of children (4/5 and 7 year olds) and by adults, in response to sentences with presuppositions and ones with either ‘direct’ or ‘indirect’ scalar implicatures. The main finding was that the behavior of children and adults differed across inference types. This asymmetry is consistent with the traditional perspective, but poses a challenge for the more recent uniform accounts. We discuss how the latter could be amended to account for these findings, and also relate the findings to previous results on presupposition processing. Finally, we discuss an unexpected difference found between direct and indirect scalar implicatures.",
keywords = "Child language acquisition, Pragmatics, Presuppositions, Scalar implicatures",
author = "Cory Bill and Jacopo Romoli and Florian Schwarz and Stephen Crain",
year = "2016",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s11245-014-9276-1",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "57--71",
journal = "Topoi",
issn = "0167-7411",
publisher = "Springer, Springer Nature",
number = "1",

}

Scalar Implicatures Versus Presuppositions : The View from Acquisition. / Bill, Cory; Romoli, Jacopo; Schwarz, Florian; Crain, Stephen.

In: Topoi, Vol. 35, No. 1, 01.04.2016, p. 57-71.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Scalar Implicatures Versus Presuppositions

T2 - Topoi

AU - Bill, Cory

AU - Romoli, Jacopo

AU - Schwarz, Florian

AU - Crain, Stephen

PY - 2016/4/1

Y1 - 2016/4/1

N2 - This paper reports an experimental investigation of presuppositions and scalar implicatures in language acquisition. Recent proposals (Chemla 2009; Romoli 2012, Romoli in J Semant 1–47, 2014) posit the same mechanisms for generating both types of inferences, in contrast to the traditional view. We used a Covered Box picture selection task to compare the interpretations assigned by two groups of children (4/5 and 7 year olds) and by adults, in response to sentences with presuppositions and ones with either ‘direct’ or ‘indirect’ scalar implicatures. The main finding was that the behavior of children and adults differed across inference types. This asymmetry is consistent with the traditional perspective, but poses a challenge for the more recent uniform accounts. We discuss how the latter could be amended to account for these findings, and also relate the findings to previous results on presupposition processing. Finally, we discuss an unexpected difference found between direct and indirect scalar implicatures.

AB - This paper reports an experimental investigation of presuppositions and scalar implicatures in language acquisition. Recent proposals (Chemla 2009; Romoli 2012, Romoli in J Semant 1–47, 2014) posit the same mechanisms for generating both types of inferences, in contrast to the traditional view. We used a Covered Box picture selection task to compare the interpretations assigned by two groups of children (4/5 and 7 year olds) and by adults, in response to sentences with presuppositions and ones with either ‘direct’ or ‘indirect’ scalar implicatures. The main finding was that the behavior of children and adults differed across inference types. This asymmetry is consistent with the traditional perspective, but poses a challenge for the more recent uniform accounts. We discuss how the latter could be amended to account for these findings, and also relate the findings to previous results on presupposition processing. Finally, we discuss an unexpected difference found between direct and indirect scalar implicatures.

KW - Child language acquisition

KW - Pragmatics

KW - Presuppositions

KW - Scalar implicatures

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84912567670&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11245-014-9276-1

DO - 10.1007/s11245-014-9276-1

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 57

EP - 71

JO - Topoi

JF - Topoi

SN - 0167-7411

IS - 1

ER -