Sentential negation in early child English

Rosalind Thornton, Graciela Tesan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Starting with the seminal work of Klima & Bellugi (1966) and Bellugi (1967), young English-speaking children have been observed to pass through a stage at which their negative utterances differ from those of adults. Children initially use not or no, whereas adults use negative auxiliary verbs (don't, can't, etc.). To explain the observed mismatches between child and adult language, the present study adopts Zeijlstra's (2004, 2007, 2008a, b) Negative Concord Parameter, which divides languages according to whether they interpret negation directly in the semantics with an adverb, or license it in the syntactic component, in which case the negative marker is a head and the language is a negative concord language. Our proposal is that children first hypothesize that negation is expressed with an adverb, in keeping with the more economical parameter value. Because English is exceptional in having both an adverb and a head form of negation, children must also add a negative head (i.e. n't) to their grammar. This takes considerable time as the positive input that triggers syntactic negation and negative concord is absent in the input for standard English, and children must find alternative evidence. The Negative Concord Parameter accounts for an intricate longitudinal pattern of development in child English, as non-adult structures are eliminated and a new range of structures are licensed by the grammar.

LanguageEnglish
Pages367-411
Number of pages45
JournalJournal of Linguistics
Volume49
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2013

Fingerprint

language
grammar
Negation
mismatch
license
speaking
semantics
Negative Concord
Adverb
Language
evidence
Syntax
Grammar
Utterance
Trigger
Standard English
Adult Language
Child Language
Mismatch
Auxiliary Verb

Cite this

Thornton, Rosalind ; Tesan, Graciela. / Sentential negation in early child English. In: Journal of Linguistics. 2013 ; Vol. 49, No. 2. pp. 367-411.
@article{784823514bf949e58ccecfe9f016a5cf,
title = "Sentential negation in early child English",
abstract = "Starting with the seminal work of Klima & Bellugi (1966) and Bellugi (1967), young English-speaking children have been observed to pass through a stage at which their negative utterances differ from those of adults. Children initially use not or no, whereas adults use negative auxiliary verbs (don't, can't, etc.). To explain the observed mismatches between child and adult language, the present study adopts Zeijlstra's (2004, 2007, 2008a, b) Negative Concord Parameter, which divides languages according to whether they interpret negation directly in the semantics with an adverb, or license it in the syntactic component, in which case the negative marker is a head and the language is a negative concord language. Our proposal is that children first hypothesize that negation is expressed with an adverb, in keeping with the more economical parameter value. Because English is exceptional in having both an adverb and a head form of negation, children must also add a negative head (i.e. n't) to their grammar. This takes considerable time as the positive input that triggers syntactic negation and negative concord is absent in the input for standard English, and children must find alternative evidence. The Negative Concord Parameter accounts for an intricate longitudinal pattern of development in child English, as non-adult structures are eliminated and a new range of structures are licensed by the grammar.",
author = "Rosalind Thornton and Graciela Tesan",
year = "2013",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1017/S0022226712000382",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "367--411",
journal = "Journal of Linguistics",
issn = "0022-2267",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "2",

}

Sentential negation in early child English. / Thornton, Rosalind; Tesan, Graciela.

In: Journal of Linguistics, Vol. 49, No. 2, 07.2013, p. 367-411.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sentential negation in early child English

AU - Thornton, Rosalind

AU - Tesan, Graciela

PY - 2013/7

Y1 - 2013/7

N2 - Starting with the seminal work of Klima & Bellugi (1966) and Bellugi (1967), young English-speaking children have been observed to pass through a stage at which their negative utterances differ from those of adults. Children initially use not or no, whereas adults use negative auxiliary verbs (don't, can't, etc.). To explain the observed mismatches between child and adult language, the present study adopts Zeijlstra's (2004, 2007, 2008a, b) Negative Concord Parameter, which divides languages according to whether they interpret negation directly in the semantics with an adverb, or license it in the syntactic component, in which case the negative marker is a head and the language is a negative concord language. Our proposal is that children first hypothesize that negation is expressed with an adverb, in keeping with the more economical parameter value. Because English is exceptional in having both an adverb and a head form of negation, children must also add a negative head (i.e. n't) to their grammar. This takes considerable time as the positive input that triggers syntactic negation and negative concord is absent in the input for standard English, and children must find alternative evidence. The Negative Concord Parameter accounts for an intricate longitudinal pattern of development in child English, as non-adult structures are eliminated and a new range of structures are licensed by the grammar.

AB - Starting with the seminal work of Klima & Bellugi (1966) and Bellugi (1967), young English-speaking children have been observed to pass through a stage at which their negative utterances differ from those of adults. Children initially use not or no, whereas adults use negative auxiliary verbs (don't, can't, etc.). To explain the observed mismatches between child and adult language, the present study adopts Zeijlstra's (2004, 2007, 2008a, b) Negative Concord Parameter, which divides languages according to whether they interpret negation directly in the semantics with an adverb, or license it in the syntactic component, in which case the negative marker is a head and the language is a negative concord language. Our proposal is that children first hypothesize that negation is expressed with an adverb, in keeping with the more economical parameter value. Because English is exceptional in having both an adverb and a head form of negation, children must also add a negative head (i.e. n't) to their grammar. This takes considerable time as the positive input that triggers syntactic negation and negative concord is absent in the input for standard English, and children must find alternative evidence. The Negative Concord Parameter accounts for an intricate longitudinal pattern of development in child English, as non-adult structures are eliminated and a new range of structures are licensed by the grammar.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84878329361&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S0022226712000382

DO - 10.1017/S0022226712000382

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 367

EP - 411

JO - Journal of Linguistics

T2 - Journal of Linguistics

JF - Journal of Linguistics

SN - 0022-2267

IS - 2

ER -