Statistical shape models of the posterior cranial fossa and hindbrain volumes may provide a more robust clinical metric for Chiari malformation

Chiari malformation is characterised by the herniation of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum. However, tonsillar herniation and other 2D morphometric measurements of the posterior cranial fossa (PCF) have a weak association with patients’ symptoms and clinical outcomes. This study aimed to contrast current 2D metrics with a novel 3D shape analysis of the PCF and the hindbrain, to determine if 3D measurements provides further insight into the pathophysiology of Chiari. The cranium of 12 controls and 21 Chiari malformation patients with (N = 9) and without (N = 12) a syrinx were scanned. The morphology of the PCF was quantified with typical 2D measurements. Additionally, a correspondence-based shape model that normalised the PCF volume, was used to find 3D differences in the shape of the PCF, and the distance of the hindbrain from the inner surfaces of the PCF. Shape analysis showed that, compared to controls, the caudal (p = 0.007; 2.3 mm, IQR: 1.6–3.3 mm) and anterior (p = 0.027; 1.3 mm,IQR: 1.1–1.6 mm) surfaces of the hindbrain were closer to the PCF in patients with and without a syrinx, respectively. However, there were negligible differences in the shape of the PCF between patient groups (p > 0.39). Current morphometric measures should be normalised for variation in PCF volume, so that shape measures are not biased. The reduced CSF space between the hindbrain and PCF will alter CSF dynamics, which may compress cerebellar vasculature and contribute to patient symptomatology.