The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica: An example from Davis station, East Antarctica

Jonathan S. Stark, Patricia A. Corbett, Glenn Dunshea, Glenn Johnstone, Catherine King, Julie A. Mondon, Michelle L. Power, Angelingifta Samuel, Ian Snape, Martin Riddle

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

We present a comprehensive scientific assessment of the environmental impacts of an Antarctic wastewater ocean outfall, at Davis station in East Antarctica. We assessed the effectiveness of current wastewater treatment and disposal requirements under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Macerated wastewater has been discharged from an outfall at Davis since the failure of the secondary treatment plant in 2005. Water, sediment and wildlife were tested for presence of human enteric bacteria and antibiotic resistance mechanisms. Epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities were tested for differences between sites near the outfall and controls. Local fish were examined for evidence of histopathological abnormalities. Sediments, fish and gastropods were tested for uptake of sewage as measured by stable isotopes of N and C. Escherichia coli carrying antibiotic resistance determinants were found in water, sediments and wildlife (the filter feeding bivalve Laternula eliptica). Fish (Trematomus bernacchii) within close proximity to the outfall had significantly more severe and greater occurrences of histopathological abnormalities than at controls, consistent with exposure to sewage. There was significant enrichment of 15N in T. bernacchii and the predatory gastropod Neobuccinum eatoni around the outfall, providing evidence of uptake of sewage. There were significant differences between epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities at control and outfall sites (<1.5 km), when sites were separated into groups of similar habitat types. Benthic community composition was also strongly related to habitat and environmental drivers such as sea ice. The combined evidence indicated that the discharge of wastewater from the Davis outfall is causing environmental impacts. These findings suggest that conditions in Antarctic coastal locations, such as Davis, are unlikely to be conducive to initial dilution and rapid dispersal of wastewater as required under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Current minimum requirements for wastewater treatment and disposal in Antarctica are insufficient to ameliorate these risks and are likely to lead to accumulation of contaminants and introduction of non-native microbes and associated genetic elements. This new understanding suggests that modernised approaches to the treatment and disposal of wastewater are required in Antarctica. The most effective solution is advanced levels of wastewater treatment, which are now possible, feasible and a high priority for installation. As a direct outcome of the study, a new advanced treatment system is being installed at Davis, effectively avoiding environmental risks.

LanguageEnglish
Pages602-614
Number of pages13
JournalWater Research
Volume105
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Nov 2016

Fingerprint

Outfalls
Sewage
Environmental impact
Wastewater
environmental impact
sewage
wastewater
Sediments
Antarctic Treaty
antibiotic resistance
sediment
Wastewater disposal
abnormality
Wastewater treatment
Fish
gastropod
environmental protection
International cooperation
fish
Antibiotics

Keywords

  • Antibiotic resistance
  • Benthic communities
  • Coastal ecosystem
  • Escherichia coli
  • Pollution
  • Stable isotopes

Cite this

Stark, J. S., Corbett, P. A., Dunshea, G., Johnstone, G., King, C., Mondon, J. A., ... Riddle, M. (2016). The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica: An example from Davis station, East Antarctica. Water Research, 105, 602-614. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2016.09.026
Stark, Jonathan S. ; Corbett, Patricia A. ; Dunshea, Glenn ; Johnstone, Glenn ; King, Catherine ; Mondon, Julie A. ; Power, Michelle L. ; Samuel, Angelingifta ; Snape, Ian ; Riddle, Martin. / The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica : An example from Davis station, East Antarctica. In: Water Research. 2016 ; Vol. 105. pp. 602-614.
@article{8cb74e55d44d4555ae0bda946bb36a7d,
title = "The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica: An example from Davis station, East Antarctica",
abstract = "We present a comprehensive scientific assessment of the environmental impacts of an Antarctic wastewater ocean outfall, at Davis station in East Antarctica. We assessed the effectiveness of current wastewater treatment and disposal requirements under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Macerated wastewater has been discharged from an outfall at Davis since the failure of the secondary treatment plant in 2005. Water, sediment and wildlife were tested for presence of human enteric bacteria and antibiotic resistance mechanisms. Epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities were tested for differences between sites near the outfall and controls. Local fish were examined for evidence of histopathological abnormalities. Sediments, fish and gastropods were tested for uptake of sewage as measured by stable isotopes of N and C. Escherichia coli carrying antibiotic resistance determinants were found in water, sediments and wildlife (the filter feeding bivalve Laternula eliptica). Fish (Trematomus bernacchii) within close proximity to the outfall had significantly more severe and greater occurrences of histopathological abnormalities than at controls, consistent with exposure to sewage. There was significant enrichment of 15N in T. bernacchii and the predatory gastropod Neobuccinum eatoni around the outfall, providing evidence of uptake of sewage. There were significant differences between epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities at control and outfall sites (<1.5 km), when sites were separated into groups of similar habitat types. Benthic community composition was also strongly related to habitat and environmental drivers such as sea ice. The combined evidence indicated that the discharge of wastewater from the Davis outfall is causing environmental impacts. These findings suggest that conditions in Antarctic coastal locations, such as Davis, are unlikely to be conducive to initial dilution and rapid dispersal of wastewater as required under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Current minimum requirements for wastewater treatment and disposal in Antarctica are insufficient to ameliorate these risks and are likely to lead to accumulation of contaminants and introduction of non-native microbes and associated genetic elements. This new understanding suggests that modernised approaches to the treatment and disposal of wastewater are required in Antarctica. The most effective solution is advanced levels of wastewater treatment, which are now possible, feasible and a high priority for installation. As a direct outcome of the study, a new advanced treatment system is being installed at Davis, effectively avoiding environmental risks.",
keywords = "Antibiotic resistance, Benthic communities, Coastal ecosystem, Escherichia coli, Pollution, Stable isotopes",
author = "Stark, {Jonathan S.} and Corbett, {Patricia A.} and Glenn Dunshea and Glenn Johnstone and Catherine King and Mondon, {Julie A.} and Power, {Michelle L.} and Angelingifta Samuel and Ian Snape and Martin Riddle",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.watres.2016.09.026",
language = "English",
volume = "105",
pages = "602--614",
journal = "Water Research",
issn = "0043-1354",
publisher = "Pergamon-Elsevier Science",

}

Stark, JS, Corbett, PA, Dunshea, G, Johnstone, G, King, C, Mondon, JA, Power, ML, Samuel, A, Snape, I & Riddle, M 2016, 'The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica: An example from Davis station, East Antarctica', Water Research, vol. 105, pp. 602-614. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2016.09.026

The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica : An example from Davis station, East Antarctica. / Stark, Jonathan S.; Corbett, Patricia A.; Dunshea, Glenn; Johnstone, Glenn; King, Catherine; Mondon, Julie A.; Power, Michelle L.; Samuel, Angelingifta; Snape, Ian; Riddle, Martin.

In: Water Research, Vol. 105, 15.11.2016, p. 602-614.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The environmental impact of sewage and wastewater outfalls in Antarctica

T2 - Water Research

AU - Stark, Jonathan S.

AU - Corbett, Patricia A.

AU - Dunshea, Glenn

AU - Johnstone, Glenn

AU - King, Catherine

AU - Mondon, Julie A.

AU - Power, Michelle L.

AU - Samuel, Angelingifta

AU - Snape, Ian

AU - Riddle, Martin

PY - 2016/11/15

Y1 - 2016/11/15

N2 - We present a comprehensive scientific assessment of the environmental impacts of an Antarctic wastewater ocean outfall, at Davis station in East Antarctica. We assessed the effectiveness of current wastewater treatment and disposal requirements under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Macerated wastewater has been discharged from an outfall at Davis since the failure of the secondary treatment plant in 2005. Water, sediment and wildlife were tested for presence of human enteric bacteria and antibiotic resistance mechanisms. Epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities were tested for differences between sites near the outfall and controls. Local fish were examined for evidence of histopathological abnormalities. Sediments, fish and gastropods were tested for uptake of sewage as measured by stable isotopes of N and C. Escherichia coli carrying antibiotic resistance determinants were found in water, sediments and wildlife (the filter feeding bivalve Laternula eliptica). Fish (Trematomus bernacchii) within close proximity to the outfall had significantly more severe and greater occurrences of histopathological abnormalities than at controls, consistent with exposure to sewage. There was significant enrichment of 15N in T. bernacchii and the predatory gastropod Neobuccinum eatoni around the outfall, providing evidence of uptake of sewage. There were significant differences between epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities at control and outfall sites (<1.5 km), when sites were separated into groups of similar habitat types. Benthic community composition was also strongly related to habitat and environmental drivers such as sea ice. The combined evidence indicated that the discharge of wastewater from the Davis outfall is causing environmental impacts. These findings suggest that conditions in Antarctic coastal locations, such as Davis, are unlikely to be conducive to initial dilution and rapid dispersal of wastewater as required under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Current minimum requirements for wastewater treatment and disposal in Antarctica are insufficient to ameliorate these risks and are likely to lead to accumulation of contaminants and introduction of non-native microbes and associated genetic elements. This new understanding suggests that modernised approaches to the treatment and disposal of wastewater are required in Antarctica. The most effective solution is advanced levels of wastewater treatment, which are now possible, feasible and a high priority for installation. As a direct outcome of the study, a new advanced treatment system is being installed at Davis, effectively avoiding environmental risks.

AB - We present a comprehensive scientific assessment of the environmental impacts of an Antarctic wastewater ocean outfall, at Davis station in East Antarctica. We assessed the effectiveness of current wastewater treatment and disposal requirements under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Macerated wastewater has been discharged from an outfall at Davis since the failure of the secondary treatment plant in 2005. Water, sediment and wildlife were tested for presence of human enteric bacteria and antibiotic resistance mechanisms. Epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities were tested for differences between sites near the outfall and controls. Local fish were examined for evidence of histopathological abnormalities. Sediments, fish and gastropods were tested for uptake of sewage as measured by stable isotopes of N and C. Escherichia coli carrying antibiotic resistance determinants were found in water, sediments and wildlife (the filter feeding bivalve Laternula eliptica). Fish (Trematomus bernacchii) within close proximity to the outfall had significantly more severe and greater occurrences of histopathological abnormalities than at controls, consistent with exposure to sewage. There was significant enrichment of 15N in T. bernacchii and the predatory gastropod Neobuccinum eatoni around the outfall, providing evidence of uptake of sewage. There were significant differences between epibiotic and sediment macrofaunal communities at control and outfall sites (<1.5 km), when sites were separated into groups of similar habitat types. Benthic community composition was also strongly related to habitat and environmental drivers such as sea ice. The combined evidence indicated that the discharge of wastewater from the Davis outfall is causing environmental impacts. These findings suggest that conditions in Antarctic coastal locations, such as Davis, are unlikely to be conducive to initial dilution and rapid dispersal of wastewater as required under the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty. Current minimum requirements for wastewater treatment and disposal in Antarctica are insufficient to ameliorate these risks and are likely to lead to accumulation of contaminants and introduction of non-native microbes and associated genetic elements. This new understanding suggests that modernised approaches to the treatment and disposal of wastewater are required in Antarctica. The most effective solution is advanced levels of wastewater treatment, which are now possible, feasible and a high priority for installation. As a direct outcome of the study, a new advanced treatment system is being installed at Davis, effectively avoiding environmental risks.

KW - Antibiotic resistance

KW - Benthic communities

KW - Coastal ecosystem

KW - Escherichia coli

KW - Pollution

KW - Stable isotopes

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84988935715&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.watres.2016.09.026

DO - 10.1016/j.watres.2016.09.026

M3 - Article

VL - 105

SP - 602

EP - 614

JO - Water Research

JF - Water Research

SN - 0043-1354

ER -