The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis

Jeanette Kennett, Steve Matthews

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Substance use and misuse occurs at a very high rate among people with mental health problems, and the relationship between the two conditions is complex. In this chapter we argue that treatment of substance use in dual diagnosis clients must begin from an understanding of the losses suffered by those with mental illness. We outline the fundamental condition of effective agency, unified agency, which is disrupted in mental illness, and show how this is needed to secure access to central social and moral goods such as continuing employment and satisfy Ying relationships. We argue that drug use will be disvaluable primarily in so far as it too prevents access to this set of agential goods and focuses the agent on synchronic well-being to the exclusion of diachronic well-being. The goals and methods of treatment for dual diagnosis patients should thus reflect the primary impairment to unified agency.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationEthical challenges for intervening in drug use
Subtitle of host publicationpolicy, research and treatment issues
EditorsJohn Kleinig, Stanley Einstein
Place of PublicationHuntsville, Texas
PublisherOffice of International Criminal Justice
Pages409-436
Number of pages28
ISBN (Print)0942511654
Publication statusPublished - 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

mental illness
well-being
drug use
exclusion
mental health

Keywords

  • agential goods
  • autonomy
  • synchronic well-being
  • unified agency
  • diachronic well-being
  • dual diagnosis
  • effective agency
  • ground projects
  • moral disvalue
  • moral goods
  • restorative function
  • self-medication

Cite this

Kennett, J., & Matthews, S. (2006). The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis. In J. Kleinig, & S. Einstein (Eds.), Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use: policy, research and treatment issues (pp. 409-436). Huntsville, Texas: Office of International Criminal Justice.
Kennett, Jeanette ; Matthews, Steve. / The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis. Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use: policy, research and treatment issues. editor / John Kleinig ; Stanley Einstein. Huntsville, Texas : Office of International Criminal Justice, 2006. pp. 409-436
@inbook{651055502d4041f2ab442623c64f4cce,
title = "The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis",
abstract = "Substance use and misuse occurs at a very high rate among people with mental health problems, and the relationship between the two conditions is complex. In this chapter we argue that treatment of substance use in dual diagnosis clients must begin from an understanding of the losses suffered by those with mental illness. We outline the fundamental condition of effective agency, unified agency, which is disrupted in mental illness, and show how this is needed to secure access to central social and moral goods such as continuing employment and satisfy Ying relationships. We argue that drug use will be disvaluable primarily in so far as it too prevents access to this set of agential goods and focuses the agent on synchronic well-being to the exclusion of diachronic well-being. The goals and methods of treatment for dual diagnosis patients should thus reflect the primary impairment to unified agency.",
keywords = "agential goods, autonomy, synchronic well-being, unified agency, diachronic well-being, dual diagnosis, effective agency, ground projects, moral disvalue, moral goods, restorative function, self-medication",
author = "Jeanette Kennett and Steve Matthews",
year = "2006",
language = "English",
isbn = "0942511654",
pages = "409--436",
editor = "John Kleinig and Stanley Einstein",
booktitle = "Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use",
publisher = "Office of International Criminal Justice",

}

Kennett, J & Matthews, S 2006, The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis. in J Kleinig & S Einstein (eds), Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use: policy, research and treatment issues. Office of International Criminal Justice, Huntsville, Texas, pp. 409-436.

The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis. / Kennett, Jeanette; Matthews, Steve.

Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use: policy, research and treatment issues. ed. / John Kleinig; Stanley Einstein. Huntsville, Texas : Office of International Criminal Justice, 2006. p. 409-436.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis

AU - Kennett, Jeanette

AU - Matthews, Steve

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - Substance use and misuse occurs at a very high rate among people with mental health problems, and the relationship between the two conditions is complex. In this chapter we argue that treatment of substance use in dual diagnosis clients must begin from an understanding of the losses suffered by those with mental illness. We outline the fundamental condition of effective agency, unified agency, which is disrupted in mental illness, and show how this is needed to secure access to central social and moral goods such as continuing employment and satisfy Ying relationships. We argue that drug use will be disvaluable primarily in so far as it too prevents access to this set of agential goods and focuses the agent on synchronic well-being to the exclusion of diachronic well-being. The goals and methods of treatment for dual diagnosis patients should thus reflect the primary impairment to unified agency.

AB - Substance use and misuse occurs at a very high rate among people with mental health problems, and the relationship between the two conditions is complex. In this chapter we argue that treatment of substance use in dual diagnosis clients must begin from an understanding of the losses suffered by those with mental illness. We outline the fundamental condition of effective agency, unified agency, which is disrupted in mental illness, and show how this is needed to secure access to central social and moral goods such as continuing employment and satisfy Ying relationships. We argue that drug use will be disvaluable primarily in so far as it too prevents access to this set of agential goods and focuses the agent on synchronic well-being to the exclusion of diachronic well-being. The goals and methods of treatment for dual diagnosis patients should thus reflect the primary impairment to unified agency.

KW - agential goods

KW - autonomy

KW - synchronic well-being

KW - unified agency

KW - diachronic well-being

KW - dual diagnosis

KW - effective agency

KW - ground projects

KW - moral disvalue

KW - moral goods

KW - restorative function

KW - self-medication

M3 - Chapter

SN - 0942511654

SP - 409

EP - 436

BT - Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use

A2 - Kleinig, John

A2 - Einstein, Stanley

PB - Office of International Criminal Justice

CY - Huntsville, Texas

ER -

Kennett J, Matthews S. The Moral goal of treatment in cases of dual diagnosis. In Kleinig J, Einstein S, editors, Ethical challenges for intervening in drug use: policy, research and treatment issues. Huntsville, Texas: Office of International Criminal Justice. 2006. p. 409-436