Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Uncovering the cost-effectiveness of theory-based implementation approaches: A health economic analysis of the Hide and Seek Project trial

  • Bonny Parkinson
  • , Priscilla Chan
  • , April Morrow
  • , Emily Hogden
  • , Karen Canfell
  • , Yoon-Jung Kang
  • , Michael Caruana
  • , Julia Steinberg
  • , Natalie Taylor
  • , HaSP team

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Objectives: Evidence that a healthcare intervention is clinically effective and cost-effective, and subsequently funded, does not guarantee adoption into routine clinical practice. Implementation science can improve adoption, although it also involves valuable resources. This study assessed the cost-effectiveness of a theory-based implementation approach compared with an intuition-based one, using genetic testing for Lynch syndrome as a case study.

Methods: A pragmatic 2-arm cluster randomized controlled trial (the Hide and Seek Project, HaSP) compared the approaches across 7 large Australian hospitals (N = 3321 patients). Costs associated with the implementation approaches and the strategies were collected during the trial, including initial once-off and ongoing strategy costs. Results were incorporated into a published microsimulation model (Policy1-Lynch). Costs were reported in 2021 Australian Dollars (AUD).

Results: Compared with the intuition-based approach, the theory-based approach was previously shown to significantly improve genetics services referral in patients at high risk of developing Lynch syndrome (P < .0001). The within-trial analysis found that a theory-based approach reduced once-off plus ongoing implementation costs by A$ 0.75 per patient versus an intuition-based approach over 5 years. The modeled analysis estimated that a theory-based approach increased health system costs by A$ 103.74 per colorectal cancer patient but resulted in fewer colorectal cancer deaths and more life-years gained and thus cost A$ 37 679 more per life-years gained than an intuition-based approach.

Conclusions: The theory-based approach resulted in more effective strategies and was cost-effective versus an intuition-based approach. Further research is needed to confirm these results in larger trials, other settings, and conditions.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)739-753
Number of pages15
JournalValue in Health
Volume29
Issue number5
Early online date10 Dec 2025
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2026

Bibliographical note

Copyright 2026, International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research, Inc. Published by Elsevier Inc. Version archived for private and non-commercial use with the permission of the author/s and according to publisher conditions. For further rights please contact the publisher.

Keywords

  • Lynch syndrome
  • colorectal cancer
  • trial
  • implementation science
  • cost-effectiveness
  • economic evaluation

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Uncovering the cost-effectiveness of theory-based implementation approaches: A health economic analysis of the Hide and Seek Project trial'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.
  • Hide and seek with hereditary cancer: Improving detection of colorectal cancer patients with a high risk of Lynch syndrome

    Taylor, N. (Chief Investigator), Tucker, K. (Chief Investigator), Macrae, F. (Chief Investigator), Gill, A. J. (Chief Investigator), Canfell, K. (Chief Investigator), Pachter, N. (Chief Investigator), Parkinson, B. (Primary Chief Investigator), Solomon, M. (Chief Investigator), Shaw, T. (Chief Investigator), Kench, J. G. (Chief Investigator), Mitchell, G. (Associate Investigator), Williams, R. (Associate Investigator), Lakhani, S. (Associate Investigator), Marfan, H. (Associate Investigator), Debono, D. (Associate Investigator), Long, J. (Associate Investigator), Morris, S. (Associate Investigator), Phan-Thien, K.-C. (Associate Investigator), Wright, C. M. (Associate Investigator) & Potter, M. (Associate Investigator)

    30/06/17 → 30/06/21

    Project: Research

Cite this