Urbanisation of floodplain ecosystems: weight-of-evidence and network meta-analysis elucidate multiple stressor pathways

Wendy A. Monk, Zacchaeus G. Compson, Catherine B. Choung, Kathryn L. Korbel, Natalie K. Rideout, Donald J. Baird

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Freshwater floodplains are dynamic, diverse ecosystems that represent important transition zones between terrestrial, riparian, subsurface and aquatic habitats. Given their historic importance in human development, floodplains have been exposed to a variety of pressures, which in combination have been instrumental in driving changes within these ecosystems. Here, we present an evidence-based framework to explore direct and indirect effects of pressures and stressors on floodplain ecosystems and test this structure within the urban landscape. Evidence was obtained from peer-reviewed scientific literature, focusing on effects of key pressures and stressors on receptors, including species composition (e.g., species presence-absence, diversity) and ecosystem function (e.g., biomass, decomposition). The strength of direct and indirect effects of individual and multiple stressors on biological receptors was quantified using two separate analyses: an evidence-weighted analysis and a quantitative network meta-analysis using data extracted from 131 studies. Results demonstrate the power of adopting a systematic framework to advance quantitative assessment of floodplain ecosystems affected by multiple stressors. While direct pathways were generally stronger and provided the core network skeleton, there were many more significant indirect pathways indicating evidence gaps in our mechanistic understanding of these processes. Indeed, the importance of indirect pathways (e.g. increase in impervious surface → increase in the accumulation rate of sediment nutrients) suggests that embracing complexity in network meta-analysis is a necessary step in revealing a more complete snapshot of the network. Results from the weight-of-evidence approach generally mirrored the direct pathway structure and demonstrated the strength of incorporating study quality alongside data sufficiency. Networks illustrated novel disturbance pathways (e.g., decrease in habitat structure → decrease in structure and function of aquatic and riparian assemblages) that can be used for hypothesis generation for future scientific enquiries. Our results highlight the broader applicability of adopting the proposed framework for assessing complex environments, such as floodplains.

LanguageEnglish
Pages741-752
Number of pages12
JournalScience of the Total Environment
Volume684
Early online date22 Feb 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 20 Sep 2019

Fingerprint

meta-analysis
Ecosystems
floodplain
urbanization
ecosystem
ecosystem dynamics
habitat structure
ecosystem function
data quality
accumulation rate
transition zone
skeleton
Nutrients
Sediments
Biomass
decomposition
Decomposition
disturbance
nutrient
biomass

Bibliographical note

Copyright the Author(s) 2019. Version archived for private and non-commercial use with the permission of the author/s and according to publisher conditions. For further rights please contact the publisher.

Keywords

  • ecological complexity
  • bioassessment
  • information discovery
  • literature review
  • EcoEvidence
  • netmeta

Cite this

Monk, Wendy A. ; Compson, Zacchaeus G. ; Choung, Catherine B. ; Korbel, Kathryn L. ; Rideout, Natalie K. ; Baird, Donald J. / Urbanisation of floodplain ecosystems : weight-of-evidence and network meta-analysis elucidate multiple stressor pathways. In: Science of the Total Environment. 2019 ; Vol. 684. pp. 741-752.
@article{7fea96355179458083e576ab6270f90f,
title = "Urbanisation of floodplain ecosystems: weight-of-evidence and network meta-analysis elucidate multiple stressor pathways",
abstract = "Freshwater floodplains are dynamic, diverse ecosystems that represent important transition zones between terrestrial, riparian, subsurface and aquatic habitats. Given their historic importance in human development, floodplains have been exposed to a variety of pressures, which in combination have been instrumental in driving changes within these ecosystems. Here, we present an evidence-based framework to explore direct and indirect effects of pressures and stressors on floodplain ecosystems and test this structure within the urban landscape. Evidence was obtained from peer-reviewed scientific literature, focusing on effects of key pressures and stressors on receptors, including species composition (e.g., species presence-absence, diversity) and ecosystem function (e.g., biomass, decomposition). The strength of direct and indirect effects of individual and multiple stressors on biological receptors was quantified using two separate analyses: an evidence-weighted analysis and a quantitative network meta-analysis using data extracted from 131 studies. Results demonstrate the power of adopting a systematic framework to advance quantitative assessment of floodplain ecosystems affected by multiple stressors. While direct pathways were generally stronger and provided the core network skeleton, there were many more significant indirect pathways indicating evidence gaps in our mechanistic understanding of these processes. Indeed, the importance of indirect pathways (e.g. increase in impervious surface → increase in the accumulation rate of sediment nutrients) suggests that embracing complexity in network meta-analysis is a necessary step in revealing a more complete snapshot of the network. Results from the weight-of-evidence approach generally mirrored the direct pathway structure and demonstrated the strength of incorporating study quality alongside data sufficiency. Networks illustrated novel disturbance pathways (e.g., decrease in habitat structure → decrease in structure and function of aquatic and riparian assemblages) that can be used for hypothesis generation for future scientific enquiries. Our results highlight the broader applicability of adopting the proposed framework for assessing complex environments, such as floodplains.",
keywords = "ecological complexity, bioassessment, information discovery, literature review, EcoEvidence, netmeta",
author = "Monk, {Wendy A.} and Compson, {Zacchaeus G.} and Choung, {Catherine B.} and Korbel, {Kathryn L.} and Rideout, {Natalie K.} and Baird, {Donald J.}",
note = "Copyright the Author(s) 2019. Version archived for private and non-commercial use with the permission of the author/s and according to publisher conditions. For further rights please contact the publisher.",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "20",
doi = "10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.02.253",
language = "English",
volume = "684",
pages = "741--752",
journal = "Science of the Total Environment",
issn = "0048-9697",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Urbanisation of floodplain ecosystems : weight-of-evidence and network meta-analysis elucidate multiple stressor pathways. / Monk, Wendy A.; Compson, Zacchaeus G.; Choung, Catherine B.; Korbel, Kathryn L.; Rideout, Natalie K.; Baird, Donald J.

In: Science of the Total Environment, Vol. 684, 20.09.2019, p. 741-752.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Urbanisation of floodplain ecosystems

T2 - Science of the Total Environment

AU - Monk, Wendy A.

AU - Compson, Zacchaeus G.

AU - Choung, Catherine B.

AU - Korbel, Kathryn L.

AU - Rideout, Natalie K.

AU - Baird, Donald J.

N1 - Copyright the Author(s) 2019. Version archived for private and non-commercial use with the permission of the author/s and according to publisher conditions. For further rights please contact the publisher.

PY - 2019/9/20

Y1 - 2019/9/20

N2 - Freshwater floodplains are dynamic, diverse ecosystems that represent important transition zones between terrestrial, riparian, subsurface and aquatic habitats. Given their historic importance in human development, floodplains have been exposed to a variety of pressures, which in combination have been instrumental in driving changes within these ecosystems. Here, we present an evidence-based framework to explore direct and indirect effects of pressures and stressors on floodplain ecosystems and test this structure within the urban landscape. Evidence was obtained from peer-reviewed scientific literature, focusing on effects of key pressures and stressors on receptors, including species composition (e.g., species presence-absence, diversity) and ecosystem function (e.g., biomass, decomposition). The strength of direct and indirect effects of individual and multiple stressors on biological receptors was quantified using two separate analyses: an evidence-weighted analysis and a quantitative network meta-analysis using data extracted from 131 studies. Results demonstrate the power of adopting a systematic framework to advance quantitative assessment of floodplain ecosystems affected by multiple stressors. While direct pathways were generally stronger and provided the core network skeleton, there were many more significant indirect pathways indicating evidence gaps in our mechanistic understanding of these processes. Indeed, the importance of indirect pathways (e.g. increase in impervious surface → increase in the accumulation rate of sediment nutrients) suggests that embracing complexity in network meta-analysis is a necessary step in revealing a more complete snapshot of the network. Results from the weight-of-evidence approach generally mirrored the direct pathway structure and demonstrated the strength of incorporating study quality alongside data sufficiency. Networks illustrated novel disturbance pathways (e.g., decrease in habitat structure → decrease in structure and function of aquatic and riparian assemblages) that can be used for hypothesis generation for future scientific enquiries. Our results highlight the broader applicability of adopting the proposed framework for assessing complex environments, such as floodplains.

AB - Freshwater floodplains are dynamic, diverse ecosystems that represent important transition zones between terrestrial, riparian, subsurface and aquatic habitats. Given their historic importance in human development, floodplains have been exposed to a variety of pressures, which in combination have been instrumental in driving changes within these ecosystems. Here, we present an evidence-based framework to explore direct and indirect effects of pressures and stressors on floodplain ecosystems and test this structure within the urban landscape. Evidence was obtained from peer-reviewed scientific literature, focusing on effects of key pressures and stressors on receptors, including species composition (e.g., species presence-absence, diversity) and ecosystem function (e.g., biomass, decomposition). The strength of direct and indirect effects of individual and multiple stressors on biological receptors was quantified using two separate analyses: an evidence-weighted analysis and a quantitative network meta-analysis using data extracted from 131 studies. Results demonstrate the power of adopting a systematic framework to advance quantitative assessment of floodplain ecosystems affected by multiple stressors. While direct pathways were generally stronger and provided the core network skeleton, there were many more significant indirect pathways indicating evidence gaps in our mechanistic understanding of these processes. Indeed, the importance of indirect pathways (e.g. increase in impervious surface → increase in the accumulation rate of sediment nutrients) suggests that embracing complexity in network meta-analysis is a necessary step in revealing a more complete snapshot of the network. Results from the weight-of-evidence approach generally mirrored the direct pathway structure and demonstrated the strength of incorporating study quality alongside data sufficiency. Networks illustrated novel disturbance pathways (e.g., decrease in habitat structure → decrease in structure and function of aquatic and riparian assemblages) that can be used for hypothesis generation for future scientific enquiries. Our results highlight the broader applicability of adopting the proposed framework for assessing complex environments, such as floodplains.

KW - ecological complexity

KW - bioassessment

KW - information discovery

KW - literature review

KW - EcoEvidence

KW - netmeta

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85062244352&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.02.253

DO - 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.02.253

M3 - Article

VL - 684

SP - 741

EP - 752

JO - Science of the Total Environment

JF - Science of the Total Environment

SN - 0048-9697

ER -