TY - JOUR
T1 - Whitehead et al. respond
AU - Whitehead, Ross D.
AU - Ozakinci, Gozde
AU - Stephen, Ian D.
AU - Perrett, David I.
PY - 2012/10
Y1 - 2012/10
N2 - 1(p207) Although these statements are definitive, the evidence for them is less so, deriving mostly from observational studies and various problematic research designs.2 It is entirely possible that worldwide fruit-andvegetable consumption is already at an appropriate level (or maybe even too high), and what the world's people may want to do to improve their health is consume fewer processed products like those containing refined grains and sugar. [...]a possibility would certainly give the appearance of a uniquely healthy effect, but would make fruits and vegetables no more "inadequate" in a person's diet than other unprocessed foods (e.g., nuts, whole grains, fish, wild game) that might replace processed foods; and no more inadequate than other foods that might supply appearance-benefiting yellow pigments (e.g., liver, eggs, cheese).9 In fact, if preferentially eating certain other whole foods would produce more-desirable health effects, then consuming fruits and vegetables instead could be relatively unhealthy. [...]better evidence is available, we, in public health might proceed with more cautious statements such as:
AB - 1(p207) Although these statements are definitive, the evidence for them is less so, deriving mostly from observational studies and various problematic research designs.2 It is entirely possible that worldwide fruit-andvegetable consumption is already at an appropriate level (or maybe even too high), and what the world's people may want to do to improve their health is consume fewer processed products like those containing refined grains and sugar. [...]a possibility would certainly give the appearance of a uniquely healthy effect, but would make fruits and vegetables no more "inadequate" in a person's diet than other unprocessed foods (e.g., nuts, whole grains, fish, wild game) that might replace processed foods; and no more inadequate than other foods that might supply appearance-benefiting yellow pigments (e.g., liver, eggs, cheese).9 In fact, if preferentially eating certain other whole foods would produce more-desirable health effects, then consuming fruits and vegetables instead could be relatively unhealthy. [...]better evidence is available, we, in public health might proceed with more cautious statements such as:
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84866335367&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.2105/AJPH.2012.300942
DO - 10.2105/AJPH.2012.300942
M3 - Letter
AN - SCOPUS:84866335367
SN - 0090-0036
VL - 102
SP - e3-e4
JO - American Journal of Public Health
JF - American Journal of Public Health
IS - 10
ER -