Winner of the 2009 systematic review competition: Generalized joint hypermobility and risk of lower limb joint injury during sport: A systematic review with meta-analysis

Verity Pacey, Leslie L. Nicholson, Roger D. Adams, Joanne Munn, Craig F. Munns

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Background: Generalized joint hypermobility is a highly prevalent condition commonly associated with joint injuries. The current literature has conflicting reports of the risk of joint injury in hypermobile sporting participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers. Systematic reviews have not been conclusive and no meta-analysis has been performed. Purpose: This review was undertaken to determine whether individuals with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of lower limb joint injury when undertaking sporting activities. Study Design: Systematic review with meta-analysis. Methods: Studies were identified through a search without language restrictions of PubMed, CINAHL, Embase, and SportDiscus databases from the earliest date through February 2009 with subsequent handsearching of reference lists. Inclusion criteria for studies were determined before searching and all included studies underwent methodological quality assessment by 2 independent reviewers. Meta-analyses for joint injury of the lower limb, knee, and ankle were performed using a random effects model. The difference in injury proportions between hypermobility categories was tested with the z statistic. Results: Of 4841 identified studies, 18 met all inclusion criteria with methodological quality ranging from 1 of 6 to 5 of 6. A variety of tests of hypermobility and varied cutoff points to define the presence of generalized joint hypermobility were used, so the authors determined a standardized cutoff to indicate generalized joint hypermobility. Using this criterion, a significantly increased risk of knee joint injury for hypermobile and extremely hypermobile participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers was demonstrated (P <.001), whereas no increased risk was found for ankle joint injury. For knee joint injury, a combined odds ratio of 4.69 (95% confidence interval, 1.33-16.52; P =.02) was calculated, indicating a significantly increased risk for hypermobile participants playing contact sports. Conclusion: Sport participants with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of knee joint injury during contact activities but have no altered risk of ankle joint injury.

LanguageEnglish
Pages1487-1497
Number of pages11
JournalAmerican Journal of Sports Medicine
Volume38
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2010
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Joint Instability
Athletic Injuries
Meta-Analysis
Lower Extremity
Joints
Knee Injuries
Knee Joint
Wounds and Injuries
Ankle Injuries
Ankle Joint
Sports
PubMed
Ankle
Knee
Language
Odds Ratio
Databases
Confidence Intervals

Cite this

@article{48136d15a11f44ceaea876b55116f82c,
title = "Winner of the 2009 systematic review competition: Generalized joint hypermobility and risk of lower limb joint injury during sport: A systematic review with meta-analysis",
abstract = "Background: Generalized joint hypermobility is a highly prevalent condition commonly associated with joint injuries. The current literature has conflicting reports of the risk of joint injury in hypermobile sporting participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers. Systematic reviews have not been conclusive and no meta-analysis has been performed. Purpose: This review was undertaken to determine whether individuals with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of lower limb joint injury when undertaking sporting activities. Study Design: Systematic review with meta-analysis. Methods: Studies were identified through a search without language restrictions of PubMed, CINAHL, Embase, and SportDiscus databases from the earliest date through February 2009 with subsequent handsearching of reference lists. Inclusion criteria for studies were determined before searching and all included studies underwent methodological quality assessment by 2 independent reviewers. Meta-analyses for joint injury of the lower limb, knee, and ankle were performed using a random effects model. The difference in injury proportions between hypermobility categories was tested with the z statistic. Results: Of 4841 identified studies, 18 met all inclusion criteria with methodological quality ranging from 1 of 6 to 5 of 6. A variety of tests of hypermobility and varied cutoff points to define the presence of generalized joint hypermobility were used, so the authors determined a standardized cutoff to indicate generalized joint hypermobility. Using this criterion, a significantly increased risk of knee joint injury for hypermobile and extremely hypermobile participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers was demonstrated (P <.001), whereas no increased risk was found for ankle joint injury. For knee joint injury, a combined odds ratio of 4.69 (95{\%} confidence interval, 1.33-16.52; P =.02) was calculated, indicating a significantly increased risk for hypermobile participants playing contact sports. Conclusion: Sport participants with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of knee joint injury during contact activities but have no altered risk of ankle joint injury.",
author = "Verity Pacey and Nicholson, {Leslie L.} and Adams, {Roger D.} and Joanne Munn and Munns, {Craig F.}",
year = "2010",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1177/0363546510364838",
language = "English",
volume = "38",
pages = "1487--1497",
journal = "American Journal of Sports Medicine",
issn = "0363-5465",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "7",

}

Winner of the 2009 systematic review competition : Generalized joint hypermobility and risk of lower limb joint injury during sport: A systematic review with meta-analysis. / Pacey, Verity; Nicholson, Leslie L.; Adams, Roger D.; Munn, Joanne; Munns, Craig F.

In: American Journal of Sports Medicine, Vol. 38, No. 7, 07.2010, p. 1487-1497.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Winner of the 2009 systematic review competition

T2 - American Journal of Sports Medicine

AU - Pacey, Verity

AU - Nicholson, Leslie L.

AU - Adams, Roger D.

AU - Munn, Joanne

AU - Munns, Craig F.

PY - 2010/7

Y1 - 2010/7

N2 - Background: Generalized joint hypermobility is a highly prevalent condition commonly associated with joint injuries. The current literature has conflicting reports of the risk of joint injury in hypermobile sporting participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers. Systematic reviews have not been conclusive and no meta-analysis has been performed. Purpose: This review was undertaken to determine whether individuals with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of lower limb joint injury when undertaking sporting activities. Study Design: Systematic review with meta-analysis. Methods: Studies were identified through a search without language restrictions of PubMed, CINAHL, Embase, and SportDiscus databases from the earliest date through February 2009 with subsequent handsearching of reference lists. Inclusion criteria for studies were determined before searching and all included studies underwent methodological quality assessment by 2 independent reviewers. Meta-analyses for joint injury of the lower limb, knee, and ankle were performed using a random effects model. The difference in injury proportions between hypermobility categories was tested with the z statistic. Results: Of 4841 identified studies, 18 met all inclusion criteria with methodological quality ranging from 1 of 6 to 5 of 6. A variety of tests of hypermobility and varied cutoff points to define the presence of generalized joint hypermobility were used, so the authors determined a standardized cutoff to indicate generalized joint hypermobility. Using this criterion, a significantly increased risk of knee joint injury for hypermobile and extremely hypermobile participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers was demonstrated (P <.001), whereas no increased risk was found for ankle joint injury. For knee joint injury, a combined odds ratio of 4.69 (95% confidence interval, 1.33-16.52; P =.02) was calculated, indicating a significantly increased risk for hypermobile participants playing contact sports. Conclusion: Sport participants with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of knee joint injury during contact activities but have no altered risk of ankle joint injury.

AB - Background: Generalized joint hypermobility is a highly prevalent condition commonly associated with joint injuries. The current literature has conflicting reports of the risk of joint injury in hypermobile sporting participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers. Systematic reviews have not been conclusive and no meta-analysis has been performed. Purpose: This review was undertaken to determine whether individuals with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of lower limb joint injury when undertaking sporting activities. Study Design: Systematic review with meta-analysis. Methods: Studies were identified through a search without language restrictions of PubMed, CINAHL, Embase, and SportDiscus databases from the earliest date through February 2009 with subsequent handsearching of reference lists. Inclusion criteria for studies were determined before searching and all included studies underwent methodological quality assessment by 2 independent reviewers. Meta-analyses for joint injury of the lower limb, knee, and ankle were performed using a random effects model. The difference in injury proportions between hypermobility categories was tested with the z statistic. Results: Of 4841 identified studies, 18 met all inclusion criteria with methodological quality ranging from 1 of 6 to 5 of 6. A variety of tests of hypermobility and varied cutoff points to define the presence of generalized joint hypermobility were used, so the authors determined a standardized cutoff to indicate generalized joint hypermobility. Using this criterion, a significantly increased risk of knee joint injury for hypermobile and extremely hypermobile participants compared with their nonhypermobile peers was demonstrated (P <.001), whereas no increased risk was found for ankle joint injury. For knee joint injury, a combined odds ratio of 4.69 (95% confidence interval, 1.33-16.52; P =.02) was calculated, indicating a significantly increased risk for hypermobile participants playing contact sports. Conclusion: Sport participants with generalized joint hypermobility have an increased risk of knee joint injury during contact activities but have no altered risk of ankle joint injury.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77954342949&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0363546510364838

DO - 10.1177/0363546510364838

M3 - Article

VL - 38

SP - 1487

EP - 1497

JO - American Journal of Sports Medicine

JF - American Journal of Sports Medicine

SN - 0363-5465

IS - 7

ER -